Neverending Musical Vs. Musical Game

Back when I was a member of Musicals Dot Net, this was a very popular thread. I always liked it because it exposed me to new shows...after all, I was a 14-year-old theatre greenhorn!

Try to justify your picks with a few words! I'll start.

Heathers Vs. Dear Evan Hansen

Almost, Alex. The show you picked then becomes the next one in yours, and you pit it against another show. So in this case, yours would be...

Heathers Vs. Wicked

Hairspray vs Hair

one is set in the sixties and one is the sixties - do love both though!

Updated On: 10/26/16 at 08:37 AM

Legally Blonde. I was in a high school production of Hairspray that still leaves a bad taste in my mouth.



Legally Blonde vs. Bat Boy

Legally Blonde because If/Then is terrible.

Next up: Legally Blonde vs. Beautiful

Urinetown because it is wittier, funnier and has Officer Lockstock and Little Sally.

Urinetown v. The Threepenny Opera. (too obvious?)

Actually Alex, Threepenny Opera IS in English...

But anyway, I'd say Book of Mormon because it proved that anything can be successful as a musical if done well.

The Book of Mormon Vs. Anything Goes

Updated On: 10/27/16 at 10:51 AM

The Producers because Springtime for Hitler is genius

The Producers vs Evita

Updated On: 10/27/16 at 12:33 PM

The Producers because Nathan Lane.



The Producers vs Guys and Dolls.

The Producers because I can't get through Spamalot.



The Producers vs. Young Frankenstein

As an artist, I'm obligated to pick Sunday in the Park with George.



Sunday vs. Passion

Company because it's more... accessible.

Company vs. Follies