Nominees for the 1st Annual Yankeefan Awards for Excellence in Theatre- Page 2

[pandajen14]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 3:07pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer

Best Critical Flop
Butley

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Company

Best Male Debut
Bob Martin as Man in Chair- Drowsy Chaperone

Best Female Debut
Cyndi Lauper as Jenny - Threepenny Opera

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Beth Leavel as Beatrice Stockwell as the Drowsy Chaperone - Drowsy Chaperone

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Julia Roberts as Nan/Lina - Three Days of Rain

Worst Debut Male
Carlos Leon as Filtch/Ensemble - Threepenny Opera

Best Male Replacement
Roger Bart as Leo Bloom - The Producers

Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd

Worst Male Replacement
Tony Danza as Max Bialystock - The Producers

Worst Female Replacement
Rita Wilson as Roxie Hart - Chicago

Best Understudy/Standby
Kenita Miller as Celie - The Color Purple

Freshest Long Running Show
Avenue Q

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Cynthia Nixon as Becca- Rabbit Hole

Best Return in a Bad Show
Hugh Panaro as Lestat - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
Les Miserables

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Festen

Best Show Tune
As We Stumble Along - Drowsy Chaperone

Worst Show Tune
Sure As Sun Turns to Moon - Tarzan

[Yankeefan007]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 5:43pm

The turnout thus far (between postings and PMs) has been a great deal larger than I expected.

Keep it coming!

[LyTeMyCanDyI]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 5:53pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet


Best Financial Flop
High Fidelity


Best Critical Flop

High Fidelity



Worst Flop

Hot Feet


Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]


Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Company


Best Male Debut

Stephen Lynch as Robbie Hart - Wedding Singer

Best Female Debut
Cyndi Lauper as Jenny - Threepenny Opera


Best Male Breakthrough Performance

Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Ashley Brown as Mary Poppins - Mary Poppins


Worst Broadway Debut Female

Amanda Peet as Corie Bratter - Barefoot in the Park


Worst Debut Male

Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer


Best Male Replacement

John Tartaglia as Lumiere - Beauty and the Beast


Best Female Replacement

Diana DeGarmo as Penny - Hairspray


Worst Male Replacement
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer


Worst Female Replacement
Gaelen Gilliland as Madame Morrible (understudy) - Wicked


Best Understudy/Standby

Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer


Freshest Long Running Show

Avenue Q



Best Male Return
Donny Osmond as Gaston - Beauty and the Beast


Best Female Return

Kristin Chenoweth as Eve/Princess Barbara/Ella/Passionella - Apple Tree


Best Return in a Bad Show

Will Chase as Rob - High Fidelity

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance

High Fidelity


Anticipated Let Down

Festen


Worst Americanization of an English Show
Mary Poppins


Best Show Tune

It’s Your Wedding Day - The Wedding Singer

Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

[Tchi4Lif188]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 7:15pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer

Best Critical Flop
High Fidelity

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
Evil Dead

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Stephen Lynch as Robbie Hart - Wedding Singer

Best Female Debut
Mara Davi as Maggie - A Chorus Line

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Vivian Nixon as Kalimba - Hot Feet

Worst Debut Male
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Best Male Replacement
Roger Bart as Leo Bloom - The Producers

Best Female Replacement
Ana Gasteyer as Elphaba - Wicked

Worst Male Replacement
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Worst Female Replacement
Rita Wilson as Roxie Hart - Chicago

Best Understudy/Standby
Maureen Moore as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Freshest Long Running Show
Avenue Q

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Will Chase as Rob - High Fidelity

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
The Threepenny Opera

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Mary Poppins

Best Show Tune
It’s Your Wedding Day - The Wedding Singer

Worst Show Tune
From the Dead - Lestat

[AnnaB]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 8:52pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer

Best Critical Flop
High Fidelity

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
Evil Dead

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Bob Martin as Man in Chair- Drowsy Chaperone

Best Female Debut
Julianne Moore as Nadia Blye - Vertical Hour

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Beth Leavel as Beatrice Stockwell as the Drowsy Chaperone - Drowsy Chaperone

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Julia Roberts as Nan/Lina - Three Days of Rain

Worst Debut Male
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Male Replacement
Roger Bart as Leo Bloom - The Producers

Best Female Replacement
Ana Gasteyer as Elphaba - Wicked

Worst Male Replacement
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Worst Female Replacement
Gaelen Gilliland as Madame Morrible (understudy) - Wicked

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer

Freshest Long Running Show
Hairspray

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Will Chase as Rob - High Fidelity

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
The Threepenny Opera

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Mary Poppins

Best Show Tune
As We Stumble Along - Drowsy Chaperone

Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

[bjh2114]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 8:52pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
The Times They Are A-Changin’

Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer

Best Critical Flop
Lestat

Worst Flop
Festen

Best Off-Broadway
I Love You Because

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Grey Gardens

Best Male Debut
Cast of The History Boys

Best Female Debut
Sarah Jones - Bridge and Tunnel

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Julie White as Diane - Little Dog Laughed

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Ali MacGraw as Else - Festen

Worst Debut Male
David Schwimmer as Lt. Barney Greenwald - Caine Mutiny

Best Male Replacement
Jonathan Pryce as Lawrence Jamison - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Best Female Replacement
Diana DeGarmo as Penny - Hairspray

Worst Male Replacement
Jacob Young as Lumiere - Beauty and the Beast

Worst Female Replacement
Katie Clarke as Clara Johnson - Light in the Piazza

Best Understudy/Standby
Maureen Moore as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Freshest Long Running Show
Wicked

Best Male Return
Jim Dale as Mr. Peachum- The Threepenny Opera

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
The Lieutenant of Inishmore

Anticipated Let Down
Tarzan

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Faith Healer

Best Show Tune
Stop the Show - Fame Becomes Me

Worst Show Tune
I Just Slept With Someone - High Fidelity

[Heybeenfood]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 9:15pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
Jay Johnson: The Two and Only

Best Critical Flop
Butley

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
The Clean House

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Company

Best Male Debut
Bob Martin as Man in Chair- Drowsy Chaperone

Best Female Debut
Sarah Jones - Bridge and Tunnel

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Julie White as Diane - Little Dog Laughed

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Cyndi Lauper as Jenny - Threepenny Opera

Worst Debut Male
David Schwimmer as Lt. Barney Greenwald - Caine Mutiny

Best Male Replacement
Jonathan Pryce as Lawrence Jamison - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Best Female Replacement
Eileen Atkins as Sister Aloysious - Doubt

Worst Male Replacement
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Worst Female Replacement
Rita Wilson as Roxie Hart - Chicago

Best Understudy/Standby
Maureen Moore as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Freshest Long Running Show
Avenue Q

Best Male Return
Ralph Fiennes as Frank - Faith Healer

Best Female Return
Mary Louise Wilson as Big Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show

Jim Dale as Mr. Peachum - The Threepenny Opera

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
The Lieutenant of Inishmore

Anticipated Let Down
Mary Poppins

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Losing Louie

Best Show Tune
Stop the Show - Fame Becomes Me

Worst Show Tune
Single - The Wedding Singer

[PirateSmile]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 11:36pm

I'm just wondering whether you folks who are voting for best and worst actors/replacements/breakthroughs, etc. actually saw the actors in these roles. The reason I'm asking is that I heard lots of first-hand reports that do not square with many of your choices. Or is it that people with strong opinions about policy voted just to 'send a message' to future producers/directors??... I noticed that several of the nominees who were considered crossovers from other media were summarily dissed (like Julia Roberts, Tony Danza, Usher, Constantine Maroulis), though I read many posts of people enjoying them in their roles. Are people just anxious to keep crossovers out?

I am a fan of lots of these shows and the actors in them, but since I did not have the opportunity to see any in person, I will not vote.

[ThankstoPhantom]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 11:44pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
Well

Best Critical Flop
Butley

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Cast of The History Boys

Best Female Debut
Sarah Jones - Bridge and Tunnel

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Amanda Peet as Corie Bratter - Barefoot in the Park

Worst Debut Male
David Schwimmer as Lt. Barney Greenwald - Caine Mutiny

Best Male Replacement
Ron Eldard as Father Flynn - Doubt

Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd

Worst Male Replacement
Jacob Young as Lumiere - Beauty and the Beast

Worst Female Replacement
Rebecca Pitcher as Christine Daae - Phantom of the Opera

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer

Freshest Long Running Show
Phantom of the Opera

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
Jay Johnson: The Two and Only

Anticipated Let Down
Tarzan

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Festen

Best Show Tune
Another Winter in a Summer Town - Grey Gardens

Worst Show Tune
From the Dead - Lestat

[Wickedfreak2]

Posted: 12/25/06 at 11:55pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
Well

Best Critical Flop
Butley

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Cast of The History Boys

Best Female Debut
Sarah Jones - Bridge and Tunnel

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Amanda Peet as Corie Bratter - Barefoot in the Park

Worst Debut Male
David Schwimmer as Lt. Barney Greenwald - Caine Mutiny

Best Male Replacement
Ron Eldard as Father Flynn - Doubt

Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd

Worst Male Replacement
Jacob Young as Lumiere - Beauty and the Beast

Worst Female Replacement
Rebecca Pitcher as Christine Daae - Phantom of the Opera

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer

Freshest Long Running Show
Phantom of the Opera

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
Lestat

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Festen

Best Show Tune
Another Winter in a Summer Town - Grey Gardens

Worst Show Tune
From the Dead - Lestat

[Marie2]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 12:56am

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
Well

Best Critical Flop
The Threepenny Opera


Worst Flop
Hot Feet

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Female Debut
Cyndi Lauper as Jenny - Threepenny Opera


Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Bill Nighy as Olivar Lucas - Vertical Hour

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Vivian Nixon as Kalimba - Hot Feet

Worst Debut Male
Josh Strickland as Tarzan - Tarzan


Best Male Replacement
Ron Eldard as Father Flynn - Doubt

Best Female Replacement
Diana DeGarmo as Penny - Hairspray


Worst Male Replacement
Richard Kind as Inspector Andre - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Freshest Long Running Show
Hairspray


Best Male Return
Martin Short as Himself - Fame Becomes Me


Best Female Return
Kristin Chenoweth as Eve/Princess Barbara/Ella/Passionella - Apple Tree

Best Show Tune
It’s Your Wedding Day - The Wedding Singer

Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

[yellibean2]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 11:04am

Worst Jukebox Musical
Ring of Fire

Best Financial Flop
High Fidelity

Best Critical Flop
High Fidelity

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Company

Best Male Debut
Cast of The History Boys

Best Female Debut
Mara Davi as Maggie - A Chorus Line

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Julia Roberts as Nan/Lina - Three Days of Rain

Worst Debut Male
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Best Male Replacement
Ron Eldard as Father Flynn - Doubt

Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd

Worst Male Replacement
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Worst Female Replacement
Rebecca Pitcher as Christine Daae - Phantom of the Opera

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer


Freshest Long Running Show
Phantom of the Opera

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Hugh Panaro as Lestat - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
Three Days of Rain

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Mary Poppins

Best Show Tune
Totally F*CKed - Spring Awakening

Worst Show Tune
Single - The Wedding Singer

[GYPSY1527]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 11:34am

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet


Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer


Best Critical Flop
The Threepenny Opera

Worst Flop
Hot Feet


Best Off-Broadway
I Love You Because


Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Grey Gardens
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Bob Martin as Man in Chair- Drowsy Chaperone

Best Female Debut
Lauren Ambrose as Hennie Berger - Awake and Sing
Sarah Jones - Bridge and Tunnel

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening


Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening


Best Male Replacement
John Tartaglia as Lumiere - Beauty and the Beast


Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd


Worst Male Replacement
Richard Kind as Inspector Andre - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels


Worst Female Replacement
Katie Clarke as Clara Johnson - Light in the Piazza


Best Understudy/Standby
Maureen Moore as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Freshest Long Running Show
Spamalot


Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat


Best Show Tune
As We Stumble Along - Drowsy Chaperone


Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

[Yankeefan007]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 1:50pm

There's one last category I didn't add:

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.

Choices:
Ashley Brown (Mary Poppins)
Kaitlin Hopkins (The Grinch)
Meredith Ingelsby (Beauty and the Beast)
Tyler Maynard (Mary Poppins)
Richard Easton (Coast of Utopia)


(Completely subjective, I know, but isn't it all?)

Updated On: 12/26/06 at 01:50 PM

[Flash-In-The-Pan]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 2:00pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
The Times They Are A-Changin’

Best Financial Flop
The Lieutenant of Inishmore

Best Critical Flop
High Fidelity

Worst Flop
Lestat

Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
The Lieutenant of Inishmore

Best Male Debut
Bob Martin as Man in Chair- Drowsy Chaperone

Best Female Debut
Lauren Ambrose as Hennie Berger - Awake and Sing

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Bill Nighy as Olivar Lucas - Vertical Hour

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Julie White as Diane - Little Dog Laughed

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Ali MacGraw as Else - Festen

Worst Debut Male
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Best Male Replacement
Jonathan Pryce as Lawrence Jamison - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd

Worst Male Replacement
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Worst Female Replacement
Rita Wilson as Roxie Hart - Chicago

Best Understudy/Standby
Kenita Miller as Celie - The Color Purple

Freshest Long Running Show
Spamalot

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Cynthia Nixon as Becca- Rabbit Hole

Best Return in a Bad Show
Jim Dale as Mr. Peachum - The Threepenny Opera

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
Three Days of Rain

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Festen

Best Show Tune
Another Winter in a Summer Town - Grey Gardens

Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

[JaYdOgSoN]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 2:00pm

Worst Jukebox Musical

Best Financial Flop
Jay Johnson: The Two and Only

Best Critical Flop
High Fidelity

Worst Flop
Festen

Best Off-Broadway
Evil Dead

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Jay Johnson: The Two and Only


Best Male Debut
Stephen Lynch as Robbie Hart - Wedding Singer

Best Female Debut
Julianne Moore as Nadia Blye - Vertical Hour

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Ashley Brown as Mary Poppins - Mary Poppins

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Ali MacGraw as Else - Festen

Worst Debut Male
Carlos Leon as Filtch/Ensemble - Threepenny Opera

Best Male Replacement
Jonathan Pryce as Lawrence Jamison - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Best Female Replacement
Diana DeGarmo as Penny - Hairspray


Worst Male Replacement

Worst Female Replacement
Gaelen Gilliland as Madame Morrible (understudy) - Wicked

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer

Freshest Long Running Show
Hairspray

Best Male Return
Martin Short as Himself - Fame Becomes Me

Best Female Return
Cynthia Nixon as Becca- Rabbit Hole

Best Return in a Bad Show
Will Chase as Rob - High Fidelity

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
Jay Johnson: The Two and Only
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
Festen

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Festen

Best Show Tune
It’s Your Wedding Day - The Wedding Singer

Worst Show Tune
Single - The Wedding Singer

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.
Ashley Brown (Mary Poppins)

[touchmeinthemorning]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 2:24pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Ring of Fire

Best Financial Flop
Well

Best Critical Flop
The Threepenny Opera

Worst Flop
Hot Feet

Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Stephen Lynch as Robbie Hart - Wedding Singer

Best Female Debut
Sarah Jones - Bridge and Tunnel

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Julie White as Diane - Little Dog Laughed

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Amanda Peet as Corie Bratter - Barefoot in the Park

Worst Debut Male
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Male Replacement
Jonathan Pryce as Lawrence Jamison - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Best Female Replacement
Eileen Atkins as Sister Aloysious - Doubt

Worst Male Replacement
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Worst Female Replacement
no vote

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer

Freshest Long Running Show
Hairspray

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Kristin Chenoweth as Eve/Princess Barbara/Ella/Passionella - Apple Tree

Best Return in a Bad Show
Will Chase as Rob - High Fidelity

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
Well

Anticipated Let Down
Chorus Line

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Festen

Best Show Tune
As We Stumble Along - Drowsy Chaperone

Worst Show Tune
I Just Slept With Someone - High Fidelity

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.
Tyler Maynard (Mary Poppins)

[paphillyguy]

Posted: 12/26/06 at 2:57pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
The Lieutenant of Inishmore

Best Critical Flop
The Threepenny Opera


Worst Flop
Festen


Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Cast of The History Boys


Best Female Debut
Cyndi Lauper as Jenny - Threepenny Opera

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Ali MacGraw as Else - Festen

Worst Debut Male
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Male Replacement
Jonathan Pryce as Lawrence Jamison - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Best Female Replacement
Sarah Uriarte Berry as Belle - Beauty and the Beast

Worst Male Replacement
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Worst Female Replacement
Rita Wilson as Roxie Hart - Chicago

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer
Freshest Long Running Show
Avenue Q

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
The Lieutenant of Inishmore

Anticipated Let Down
Festen


Worst Americanization of an English Show
Festen

Best Show Tune
Totally F*CKed - Spring Awakening


Worst Show Tune
From the Dead - Lestat

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.
Ashley Brown (Mary Poppins)

[NY NY]

Posted: 12/27/06 at 12:12am

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
Well

Best Critical Flop
The Threepenny Opera

Worst Flop
Hot Feet

Best Off-Broadway
I Love You Because

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Grey Gardens

Best Male Debut
Bob Martin as Man in Chair- Drowsy Chaperone

Best Female Debut
Sarah Jones - Bridge and Tunnel

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Julia Roberts as Nan/Lina - Three Days of Rain

Worst Debut Male
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Male Replacement
John Tartaglia as Lumiere - Beauty and the Beast

Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd

Worst Male Replacement
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Worst Female Replacement
Katie Clarke as Clara Johnson - Light in the Piazza

Best Understudy/Standby
Maureen Moore as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Freshest Long Running Show
Wicked

Best Male Return

Ralph Fiennes as Frank - Faith Healer

Best Female Return
Christine Ebersole as Big/Little Edie - Grey Gardens

Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat

Show To Which You'd Give a 2nd Chance
Well

Anticipated Let Down
Mary Poppins

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Losing Louie

Best Show Tune
As We Stumble Along - Drowsy Chaperone

Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared
in Disney's On The Record
Richard Easton (Coast of Utopia)

[zepka102]

Posted: 12/27/06 at 12:21am

technically, isn't "worst flop" an oxymoron :-P?


i hate the negativity in these awards... maybe it's cuz the categories start out with a lot of negatives

[Sab6888]

Posted: 12/27/06 at 2:38am

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer

Best Critical Flop
High Fidelity

Worst Flop
Hot Feet

Best Off-Broadway
I Love You Because

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Stephen Lynch as Robbie Hart - Wedding Singer

Best Female Debut
Julianne Moore as Nadia Blye - Vertical Hour

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
John Gallagher, Jr. as Moritz - Spring Awakening

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Vivian Nixon as Kalimba - Hot Feet

Worst Debut Male
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Male Replacement
John Tartaglia as Lumiere - Beauty and the Beast

Best Female Replacement
Diana DeGarmo as Penny - Hairspray

Worst Male Replacement
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Worst Female Replacement
Rita Wilson as Roxie Hart - Chicago

Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer

Freshest Long Running Show
Wicked

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Kristin Chenoweth as Eve/Princess Barbara/Ella/Passionella - Apple Tree

Best Return in a Bad Show
Patrick Wilson as Paul Bratter - Barefoot in the Park

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
The Threepenny Opera

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Losing Louie

Best Show Tune
It’s Your Wedding Day - The Wedding Singer

Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.
Ashley Brown (Mary Poppins)

[dancingthrulife04]

Posted: 12/27/06 at 9:30am

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.

Ashley Brown (Mary Poppins)

[JudasIscariot]

Posted: 12/27/06 at 11:46am

Worst Jukebox Musical
Hot Feet

Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer

Best Critical Flop
Lestat

Worst Flop
Hot Feet

Best Off-Broadway
[title of show]

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Spring Awakening

Best Male Debut
Stephen Lynch as Robbie Hart - Wedding Singer

Best Female Debut
Mara Davi as Maggie - A Chorus Line


Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company


Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Lea Michele as Wendla - Spring Awakening


Worst Broadway Debut Female
Julia Roberts as Nan/Lina - Three Days of Rain


Worst Debut Male
Josh Strickland as Tarzan - Tarzan


Best Male Replacement
Jonathan Pryce as Lawrence Jamison - Dirty Rotten Scoundrels


Best Female Replacement
Sarah Uriarte Berry as Belle - Beauty and the Beast

Worst Male Replacement
Usher as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Worst Female Replacement
Rita Wilson as Roxie Hart - Chicago


Best Understudy/Standby
Tina Maddigan as Julia Sullivan - The Wedding Singer


Freshest Long Running Show
Wicked

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Kristin Chenoweth as Eve/Princess Barbara/Ella/Passionella - Apple Tree


Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
The Threepenny Opera


Anticipated Let Down
Three Days of Rain


Worst Americanization of an English Show
Mary Poppins

Best Show Tune
It’s Your Wedding Day - The Wedding Singer

Worst Show Tune
Sure As Sun Turns to Moon - Tarzan

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.
Ashley Brown (Mary Poppins)

[LuPonatic]

Posted: 12/27/06 at 2:49pm

Worst Jukebox Musical
The Times They Are A-Changin’

Best Financial Flop
The Wedding Singer

Best Critical Flop
High Fidelity


Worst Flop
Hot Feet

Best Off-Broadway
Evil Dead

Show Which Most Deserved that Broadway Transfer
Grey Gardens

Best Male Debut
Harry Connick, Jr. as Sid Sorokin - Pajama Game

Best Female Debut
Julianne Moore as Nadia Blye - Vertical Hour

Best Male Breakthrough Performance
Marc Shaiman as Himself - Martin Short: Fame Becomes Me

Best Female Breakthrough Performance
Beth Leavel as Beatrice Stockwell as the Drowsy Chaperone - Drowsy Chaperone

Worst Broadway Debut Female
Cyndi Lauper as Jenny - Threepenny Opera

Worst Debut Male
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Best Male Replacement
Huey Lewis as Billy Flynn - Chicago

Best Female Replacement
Judy Kaye as Mrs. Lovett - Sweeney Todd

Worst Male Replacement
Constantine Maroulis as Sammy - Wedding Singer

Worst Female Replacement
Rebecca Pitcher as Christine Daae - Phantom of the Opera

Best Understudy/Standby
Kenita Miller as Celie - The Color Purple

Freshest Long Running Show
Spamalot

Best Male Return
Raul Esparza as Robert - Company

Best Female Return
Kristin Chenoweth as Eve/Princess Barbara/Ella/Passionella - Apple Tree

Best Return in a Bad Show
Carolee Carmello as Gabrielle - Lestat

Show To Which You’d Give a 2nd Chance
High Fidelity

Anticipated Let Down
Three Days of Rain

Worst Americanization of an English Show
Losing Louie

Best Show Tune
Stop the Show - Fame Becomes Me

Worst Show Tune
Big Titties - Fame Becomes Me

Best Actor Currently on Broadway Who Has Appeared in Disney's On The Record.
Ashley Brown (Mary Poppins)

[Yankeefan007]

Posted: 12/28/06 at 3:55pm

Last bump