As I promised myself yesterday, I listened to the CD's of DO RE MI, both the OBCR and the Encores! production. Although the Encores! CD is more complete, the OBCR is superior in several ways. First, the leads are better. Phil Silvers singing "All of My Life" is more poignant than Nathan Lane's rendition. Nancy Walker's "Adventure" is classic Walker. John Reardon's "Make Someone Happy", a gem of a showtune, is beautifully sung. Nancy Dussault's singing is pure "Broadway". And above all, the orchestra, under the pit conductor Lehman Engel, is fuller and more energized than the Encores! orchestra, despite the conducting of the usually reliable Paul Gemignani. Listen to the overtures of the two recordings and the difference is immediately apparent. The OBCR makes you sit up and take notice. As Smaxie pointed out, the orchestrations by Luther Henderson are terrific and Engel brings out the best from his orchestra.
Incidentally, on another note, it was the studio cast recording of PAL JOEY by Lehman Engel in 1950, a popular success, that motivated Jule Styne to produce the revival of PAL JOEY in 1952.
"Madam Rose...and her daughter...Gypsy!"