I have to say it was pretty bad. The songs were so-so, and the book worse than that. I guess the major problem was that the premise didn't fly. I didn't believe it for a minute. Alexis Smith was excellent, though.
The revised version with Tammy Grimes was presented off-Broadway under the title of "Sunset." It was recorded, and it's on cd.
Alexis Smith received a Tony nomination for her performance, but the show's failure meant that for the remainder of her career (she died in the mid-'90s) she was relegated to touring and stock productions....shades of her Platinum role. The score has some fine songs interspersed with...egads, disco boogies! Only in the '70s.
There was no joy for me in seeing flops on Broadway in those days. (Or now.) If only Alexis Smith had gone from Follies to originating a spectacular star turn on Broadway, it would have been exhilarating. Even if it had been something like Applause...
And, she did open the First National of Whorehouse, which ain't nothing to shake a stick at! (I think she was also the first non-Texan to play the role)
I saw it twice during its tryout in Philadelphia. Loved the music (That's why I saw it twice). It is a guilty pleasure. Chita Rivera's daughter Lisa Mordente was in it. On the second night I saw the show, Chita Rivera came flying through the lobby in a red kaftan. She didn't see me and knocked me and my cup of coca-cola to the floor! I remember looking up from the floor and seeing her leaning over me apologizing and offering to help me up and replace my drink. I declined both. I was just excited that Chita knocked me to the floor!!! lol
Here's something else I seem to recall. I think that when the show was trying out in D.C. there was a musicians strike at the time. I seem to recall that the orchestra consisted of just a handful of musicians. Did the show normally have a big orchestra?
I also just read that PLATINUM was the first Broadway show to have financial backing from a Hollywood studio.
L.A. Times September 12, 1978 Last October, Michael Eisner, president of Paramount Pictures, arrived in Buffalo during a fog that nearly kept his plane from landing to see tryouts of a Broadway possibility--a new musical called "Sunset" starring Alexis Smith. "Someone told me it was good so I went and I said, "This is good, let's do it.'"
Phyl and Infinite, it still stands out as one of my favorite "theatre experiences"! Imagine being momentarily encased in a red kaftan! (That you weren't wearing!)
A few years later on one of those PBS "Showstoppers" specials, Alexis Smith did the song "Nothin' But." Good song, but hardly a showstopper.
Cast albums are NOT "soundtracks." Live theatre does not use a "soundtrack." If it did, it wouldn't be live theatre!
I host a weekly one-hour radio program featuring cast album selections as well as songs by cabaret, jazz and theatre artists. The program, FRONT ROW CENTRE is heard Sundays 9 to 10 am and also Saturdays from 8 to 9 am (eastern times) on www.proudfm.com