For a bunch of young people playing around on social media, they're VERY good. Genuine kudos to all of them! I think it's a really fun social/artistic experiment, and most of them are doing a good job with it.
But most of the songs are pretty first-thought and simplistic, the kind of stuff that's frequently written for Broadway musical adaptations, but not the good ones. It's interesting because the big song that (seemingly) kicked this one off, "Remy the Ratatouille" is very obviously meant to be a tongue-in-cheek play on vapid -- but catchy -- musical theatre songs, and then it snowballed into this.
Again: I'm not actually criticizing these people. They're just having fun and being creative, and they're doing a great job of it. They aren't professionals who have been hired to write a cohesive show, and they shouldn't be judged as such. But people have been throwing around a lot of hyperbole about its quality, and the idea that it might become a real musical, and so this is just my two-cents on that.
Updated On: 11/21/20 at 03:45 PM