Suggestions:
-- Check several times in the early afternoon/late afternoon for non-premium Dear Evan Hansen tickets if you're still interested in that show. There's a "four-day rule" that has worked for several people who have posted here, and it worked for me too. Basically, a few tickets in the $179-$199 range usually pop up on Telecharge about four days before the show. So today (East Coast time) might be your chance.
-- You can't really go wrong with Sunset Boulevard. I didn't see it on my trip last week, but I did see Glenn Close back in the 1990s in the same role. Many people strongly recommended the revival, and plenty of inexpensive seats are available.
-- I hesitate to recommend Great Comet, if only becauase it tends to be a show that people either love or hate. I really enjoyed it last week, and I would recommend reading the 78-page section of War and Peace on which it's based beforehand - not because the plot is all that complicated, but so you can just take in what is a unique experience without getting lost. There are still seats available, and you don't need to sit up close anyway. The cost is less than $400 for two people, and there's nothing else like it on Broadway.
-- I had planned to see Significant Other, a play, on our first night there. We had plane trouble, so we didn't make it, but it's supposed to be anchored by a strong lead performance. It's closing soon, so prices are a little higher, but still within your budget.
-- If you haven't seen Six Degrees of Separation, it's a very good play that's being revived. We almost saw the revival but decided to see something else instead. But if you like Allison Janney, she's supposed to be terrific.
-- I also considered War Paint, which is supposed to be a decent musical with two veteran Broadway stars in top form.
Updated On: 4/19/17 at 02:04 AM