I don't think this is good casting, but I'm sure it'll sell out. And that's what producers are worried about. So I'm sure THEY think it's great casting.
Vanessa is a wonderful actress, but she's so very British. She's a stalwart, graceful "tree," with quiet beauty and elegance. Not an American firecracker like Daisy. And I doubt she'll convince anyone that she's southern for one minute, let alone Jewish and southern.
She's not a character actress. She's Vanessa Redgrave. An aging leading lady. Her sister Lynn was the character actress.
James Earl Jones is too old for Hoke. The play spans several decades. It's fine if Daisy starts out in her early 70s and ends up in her mid 90s, because she's the one being driven around.
Hoke should be younger. Around 50 to begin with. So he's not ready for the nursing home with her at the end of the play.
He's also too powerful for Hoke. I can't see him putting on his "Yassum" and "Noumm" and bowing and scraping for Daisy Werthan. He'll look like a bull in a China shop.
Maybe they will prove me wrong. They're both excellent actors, no question about that. But they are wrong for these roles, so they will have their work cut out for them. I just hope they show up to the theatre ready to work and work hard. If not, this will be a disappointing sold-out production.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Updated On: 6/30/10 at 07:34 AM