wonkit said: "I love Santino, too. I saw him in EARNEST (in which he stole every scene), CINDERELLA, and ZORBA but the performance that blew me away was as John Adams in 1776. I thought he wasn't ideally cast - perhaps a bit too young or likable? - but he was excellent throughout. I'm not sure about Bobby in COMPANY (again, too likable?) but definitely The Baker, and , in a few years, George in SITPWG.
I don't think he's too "likable" to play Bobby. He plays a pretty jaded character on Crazy Ex Girlfriend and I think he would do a great job. Also, I don't think likability is a problem for Bobby as it gives the audience more of a reason that all of his friends are obsessed with him. He's meant to be a flirty, likable guy that does a good job of hiding his insecurities and problems.