I was there. The applause for "Turn It Off" was tremendous. The other elders actually broke the pose and BOWED to Rory, some of them actually kneeling on the floor. It was great!
Hitler, McKinley and one of the devils did a kickline upstage (just under Satan) during Hell Dream.
Also got applause for his pink suitcase entrance at the end. :) After curtain, Nikki M. James did a short speech (I honestly wasn't expecting it, because Andrew Rannells and Josh Gad didn't get one) and I couldn't see who, but a cast member presented Rory with a pink Hello Kitty suitcase as a goodbye gift. I saw it outside the theatre later and it looked like a bunch of people had signed it with well wishes.
"This thread reads like a series of White House memos." — Mister Matt