SITPWG Recordings
SITPWG Recordings
Tag
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/19/05
#1SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 6:52pmWhat is recommended, the OBCR or the revival recording? And why???
#2re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 6:57pmPersonally, I would go with the OBC DVD and the revival CD. I just don't really like the OBCR, but the DVD is wonderful.
#2re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 7:10pmBernadette's vocals are much stronger on the OBCR opposed to the DVD. Just a note for you.
Tag
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/19/05
#3re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 7:15pm
I already have the DVD...
so I should go for the revival recording?
#4re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 7:19pm
Well I would recommend both. The OBCR is pretty cheap. But if you only want one...get the London recording sine you already have the DVD.
Be aware that Daniel Evans and Jenna Russell are the only cast members from the London production/recording that are in the Broadway revival. They won't be making a Broadway revival recording.
#5re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 7:29pm
I would go with London for a complete score but I love the performances on the OBCR more.
Russell fails in the shaddow of Bernadette's We Do Not Belong Together, imo.
In fact, both Patinkin and Peters' performances are more emotionally gratifying to me than Evans and Russell, I still wish I could see them though, I'm sure it's better onstage.
"If artists were machines, then I'm just a different kind of machine...I'd probably be a toaster. Actually, I'd be a toaster oven because they're more versatile. And I like making grilled cheese" -Regina Spektor
"That's, like, twelve shows! ...Or seven." -Crazy SA Fangirl
"They say that just being relaxed is the most important thing [in acting]. I take that to another level, I think kinda like yawning and...like being partially asleep onstage is also good, but whatever." - Sherie Rene Scott
Tag
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/19/05
#6re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 7:30pmI know, after seeing the revival I was hoping for a recording (if anything for Beautiful with Mary Beth Peil) but it really makes no sense, financially, to record one.
#7re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 7:37pmI have the DVD and the revival CD and I am very satisfied. iTunes has the OBCR so you may purchase the songs that you like as singles. Enjoy.
#8re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 9:18pmThe orchestrations on the OBCR are superior to the revival recording.
#9re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 9:50pmI personally think that the OBCR is definite and as much as I enjoy Evans and Russell, I think the magic that the likes of Mandy Patinkin, Bernadette Peters (in what might be her definite role, along with Mabel Normand and Ruby), Dana Ivey (I didn't realize how brilliant she was as Yvonne until I listened to Sadovy and saw Molaskey), Barbara Bryne, Charles Kimbrough, Brent Spiner, and Robert Westenberg (just to mention a few of the performers) is not matched by the revival recording. Both are strong recordings of a brilliant score, but ultimately the OBCR wins this race.
#10re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 11:08pmI'm going to be different and say the London recording. The orchestrations are not as good, but I personally prefer the vocals.
The choice may have been mistaken, The choosing was not... "Every day has the potential to be the greatest day of your life." - Lin-Manuel Miranda
zooxanthellae
Broadway Star Joined: 6/2/07
#11re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/21/08 at 11:10pmI like the original recording much more than the revival. Fuller orchestrations and Bernadette is stunning on it!
#12re: SITPWG Recordings
Posted: 3/22/08 at 9:49amI think the OBCR is a better recording, but I listen to the LCR more because I’d rather listen to the more complete recording. So I guess it depends on what you want. If you have the DVD already, I would recommend the LCR.
Videos