hork said: "Meh, I'm not seeing anything special about Rebel Wilson. Maybe if it were an amateur talent show I'd think, "Hey, she's pretty good."
Plus, Pat Carroll is incomparable."
I only saw the YouTube of this, so there may be something I wasn't privy to, but count me in with the folks who agree with you, especially regarding the 'amateur talent show' comment.
I think Rebel is always good when she plays "Rebel", but applying that comedic character to Ursula didn't fit. Even her entrance foretold that she was not aiming to play a 'smarmy villianess'.
Pat Carroll was, indeed incomparable. I think the biggest mistake made when live-casting the role (i.e., Sheree Renee Scott) is choosing an actress with a beautiful voice. If the actress playing the role doesn't have the vocal quality of Harvey Firestein, why would she covet Ariel's voice? (...with the advantage Carroll's singing had of being listenable, in spite of her rasp.)
Not to get too off-topic, but the other Disney villianess actor who played a similarly perfect 'smarm' was Geraldine Page in The Rescuers. I can still hear her saying, "Adopted? What makes you think anyone would want a homely little girl like you?"
Updated On: 6/6/16 at 09:08 AM