The Play That Goes Wrong is a ton of fun, but only if you abandon all intellect at the door. It's total slapstick, low-brow humor, but I personally loved it (and I'm usually into super witty stuff, so it was actually surprising how much I enjoyed it).
It's not on your list, but I always throw The Great Comet out there. It's the best show of the season imo, but you have to be open to, well, weirdness, because it's not at all like a normal Bway show.
Off your list, though, the only other one I'd probably recommend is Bandstand, assuming it's still open come fall. It's not a particularly good show, but it's a lot of fun and the choreography is amazing, if you're into dance-y shows.