Short show rec for Wed 4/17 PM

I have to catch a train at Penn station at 10:05 PM on Wednesday, April 17. So I think I have time to add one more show to my trip, as long as it’s over in midtown at or before about 9:30 PM. Unfortunately, it looks like the current slate of shows are all pretty lengthy, and a lot of shows that normally start at 7:00 PM on Wednesdays have 8:00 PM curtains on 4/17. Does anyone have a recommendation for something they loved, either that starts at 7:00 PM or earlier that night, or that is short enough that I’ll be out by 9:30 PM so that I can make my train? Things I’ve seen—or will have seen by then—include Ain't No Mo, What the Constitution Means to Me, and Come From Away. So far, Waitress is my top contender, even though I’ve seen it before, but I might like to see the new cast. Is that my best bet?

Updated On: 4/14/19 at 11:03 AM

I don't know if this is your thing but I believe both Gary and Hillary and Clinton are rather short and without an intermission.

annang said: "poisonivy2 said: "I don't know if this is your thing but I believe both Gary and Hillary and Clinton are rather short and without an intermission."

Have you seen them? Which one would you recommend? A friend who saw both recommended neither, but I’m open to second opinions."

I haven't. And to be honest neither interest me. I forgot to add that What the Constitution Means to Me is also a 100 minute intermissionless show.

But if your heart is set on Waitress go for it. I've seen the show five times and the run-time is consistent. It's about 2.5 hours. So you'll be out of there by 9:40 tops which is plenty of time to get to Penn Station.

poisonivy2 said: "annang said: "poisonivy2 said: "I don't know if this is your thing but I believe both Gary and Hillary and Clinton are rather short and without an intermission."

Have you seen them? Which one would you recommend? A friend who saw both recommended neither, but I’m open to second opinions."

I haven't. And to be honest neither interest me. I forgot to add that What the Constitution Means to Me is also a 100 minute intermissionless show.

But if your heart is set on Waitress go for it. I've seen the show five times and the run-time is consistent. It's about 2.5 hours. So you'll be out of there by 9:40 tops which is plenty of time to get to Penn Station."

Yup, I mentioned Constitution in my post. I’ve seen it. I’ve also done Waitress a few times and wouldn’t be sad to see it again. Just wanted to check out other options. Thanks!

What the Constitution Means to Me for sure! Easily one of the best things of the season.

What the Constitution Means to Me and Come From Away are two of the shows I named in my original post as ones I wasn’t interested in, sorry. I hated Come From Away (I know, me and Peter Marks are the only people who didn’t like it). Constitution, loved the first hour, hated the second hour.

I think I’m going to go see Lee Pace in Nassim at City Center. Didn’t register on my radar at first, but he’s one of my favorites.