The great thing about musicals is that the songs have a story, so...have you ever listened to a cast album and gone, "...they wrote a song about THIS? What?"
Broadway Star Joined: 7/9/08
I'd say (way back when) electroshock therapy in "Feeling Electric" is out of the norm. And a variety of songs from Sweeny about making humans and other creatures into pies.
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/19/06
I'm still confused about the song in Seesaw, where they teach Ken Howard "Spanglish"
Well, the first thing that came to my head were some of the Avenue Q songs, like "I'm Not Wearing Underwear Today" and "The Internet is For Porn," but those kind of songs make that show so real and hilarious.
Understudy Joined: 7/29/07
"Unfortunate Erection"
"Dance 10, Looks 3"
"Contact" - rent
"Sodomy" - hair
"The Rape of Miss Goldberg" - trousers
"Kesa" - See What I Wanna See
"Think of Meryl Streep" - Fame
"Internet is for Porn"
A Little Priest - Sweeney Todd
Hominy Grits - Grey Gardens
Entering Grey Gardens - Grey Gardens
Listen to BAJOUR for a terrific song (really!)about African tribes and tse-tse flies.
"Genius" from Flight of the Lawnchair Man. Leonardo Da Vinci leads an enthusiastic dance number. It lives up to its title.
"Ruffhousin' Mit Shuffhausen" from Dirty Rotten Scoundrels comes to mind as well.
Stand-by Joined: 6/18/08
Essentially any song from Assassins.
"The Sensitive Song"
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/8/08
"Didn't I See This Movie?" -Next to Normal
"Feed Me" -Little Shop of Horrors
I would have to say nearly every song from Act II of Grey Gardens. I'm assuming that's the first showtune written about corn?
Not from a show, but a song called "Poor Little Patty." It's about Patty Hearst. Random subject matter.
Understudy Joined: 12/5/08
"Hello, Little Girl" from INTO THE WOODS is a little sketchy out of context. Well, in context for that matter too.
I immediately thought Coffee from See What I Wanna See.
"Fiddle About" from The Who's Tommy. A song about an uncle molesting his nephew. Yeah... awkward.
'Wick' from The Secret Garden. Sure, it means something in the story, but it really didn't justify a song. I feel the same about 'This Was a Real Nice Clambake' from Carousel and loads from Hair.
Lots of the songs from URINETOWN, like 'It's a Privilege to Pee'
I'm Small from Dude
I don't know if these are weird, as such, but I know a whole bunch of songs about masturbation, such as 'Jack's Song' from Naked Boys Singing (which is also embarrassingly catchy) and half of Spring Awakening, and 'Come to Jesus' from Myths and Hymns is almost certainly about abortion. Although the closest I can find to premature ejaculation is 'My Unfortunate Erection' (actually, 'Contact' from Rent sounds like there might be some premature ejaculation in there somewhere... must investigate further).
Really, a GREAT MANY showtunes are about WTF subject matter. Hell, WHOPLE SHOWS are about WTF subject matter! Bearing that in mind, it's really not hard to find a song that makes you go O_O when it's out of context. Although the ones that invoke that reaction even when in context, those are the special ones. :)
EDIT: oh, and 'Big Ass Rock' from The Full Monty is about assisted suicide. David Yazbek seems to have written a few WTF songs. XD
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/27/05
Awwww, "Wick" is one of my favorite songs from TSG.
Featured Actor Joined: 8/21/08
I totally agree with "I'm Small". I was "Ed" in You Can't Take it With You" and I made my 'mazurka' the overture from Dude. So naturally I had the score stuck in my head and was singing offstage. And I got to the part of "I'm Small" where it's like "but not big enough for your big fat a++" and one of my friends only heard that part and was like "wtf" and made a huge deal about it's stupidity. We've quoted it ever since. Another WTF subject matter is "Boom Boom" from Little Me and "Out for Blood" from Carrie (surprised no one's mentioned it yet).
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/27/05
Okay, just thought of a few:
"My Psychopharmacologist and I" from N2N.
"The Call" from Floyd Collins - it's about... spelunking!
"The Factory Girls / Come Up to My Office" from Parade - about alleged sexual harassment in the workplace
Donkey Pot Pie
Videos