Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#51

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Kad said: "Apropos of nothing, here’s the block member link."

Much appreciated. Thank you. Until they come up with another alias, I can be spared reading their inane posts.

Updated On: 11/15/26 at 09:07 PM

#52

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Jordan Catalano said: "I saw this again today and loved it even more than I did the first time. I think it’s just an absolutely perfect production and everybody’s performances have gotten so much stronger since the first preview. Just a remarkably special show that I hope everybody gets a chance to see."

And if you have not seen the production go into it with an open heart. The rewards will be bountiful!

#53

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

At the request of multiple users, I will start to consolidate preview and review threads for Broadway shows.

THE FANTASTICKS opens tonight!


Imagine if we could tell everyone here that Liberty Mutual customizes car insurance to save people hundreds. (LiMu squawks)
#55

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Jordan Catalano said: "Brilliant. Many thanks."



My thoughts exactly! Thank you!

#56

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

EDSOSLO858 said: "At the request of multiple users, I will start to consolidate preview and review threads for Broadway shows.

THE FANTASTICKS opens tonight!
"

Great! And those of us who see no reason to change the way the board has operated for 20+ years because people dislike one poster can keep posting reviews in a separate thread. It's nice to have options.



#57

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

B-roll just released:


Imagine if we could tell everyone here that Liberty Mutual customizes car insurance to save people hundreds. (LiMu squawks)
#59

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

DTLI Consensus: Simplicity is the name of the game in this charming, rejiggered Fantasticks making its long-awaited Broadway bow.

9 positive, 3 mixed (including the NYT).

https://didtheylikeit.com/shows/the-fantasticks/


Imagine if we could tell everyone here that Liberty Mutual customizes car insurance to save people hundreds. (LiMu squawks)

Updated On: 11/16/26 at 11:07 PM

#60

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Vincentelli's treatment of Phillips low-key baffles me ... I agree he did not sufficiently embody a "manipulative schemer" in Act II, but that's the fault of the book and its revisions. The earlier post that criticized the elimination of the "Do you find me attractive?" ... "Somewhat" exchange between Louis and El Gallo immediately springs to mind. The updates to his character in the second act felt overly ... heteronormative, maybe? But that's on the writers, not the actor.

Moreover, it's overall a nit in the scheme of things, certainly not deserving of one of the longest and most critical grafs in the review.

And i'd call it more mixed-positive than mixed. (Yes, I'm aware that's not an option on didtheylikeit.)

#biceplivesmatter devil


"You, sir, are a moron." (PlayItAgain)
#61

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

MemorableUserName said: "EDSOSLO858 said: "At the request of multiple users, I will start to consolidate preview and review threads for Broadway shows.

THE FANTASTICKS opens tonight!
"

Great! And those of us who see no reason to change the way the board has operated for 20+ years because people dislike one poster can keep posting reviews in a separate thread. It's nice to have options.





No one said anything about disliking a poster. Interestingly enough those words are coming from you.





#62

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

79 on Broadway Scorecard, recommended. Strong choice.

"Critics largely embrace this gay reimagining of the beloved classic, praising its tender charm and Gattelli's direction, though a few find the gender-swap insufficient to freshen the dated material."

https://broadwayscorecard.com/show/the-fantasticks


Imagine if we could tell everyone here that Liberty Mutual customizes car insurance to save people hundreds. (LiMu squawks)
#63

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

MemorableUserName said: "Great! And those of us who see no reason to change the way the board has operated for 20+ years because people dislike one poster can keep posting reviews in a separate thread. It's nice to have options."

Yeah and 20+ years of doing things the same way is old and tired by definition. Making things easier by consolidating everything for each show under one thread (as it's done on the West End board) is a better user experience. It's not like CoffeeBreak hasn't given AMPLE, VALID reasons for people to dislike them. But regardless, everything in one place makes sense. Sorry you're so arsed about it, but respectfully, get over it.

You'll be ok.

#64

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

UWS10023 said: "MemorableUserName said: "EDSOSLO858 said: "At the request of multiple users, I will start to consolidate preview and review threads for Broadway shows.

THE FANTASTICKS opens tonight!
"

Great! And those of us who see no reason to change the way the board has operated for 20+ years because people dislike one poster can keep posting reviews in a separate thread. It's nice to have options.


No one said anything about disliking a poster. Interestingly enough those words are coming from you.


This you?

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews


"

#65

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Annnnnnnnnd just like that, they have yanked their discount code.

#66

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

They had inexpensive tickets available for months.


"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
#67

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

OhHiii said: "MemorableUserName said: "Great! And those of us who see no reason to change the way the board has operated for 20+ years because people dislike one poster can keep posting reviews in a separate thread. It's nice to have options."

Yeah and 20+ years of doing things the same way is old and tired by definition. Making things easier by consolidating everything for each show under one thread (as it's done on the West End board) is a better user experience. It's not like CoffeeBreak hasn't given AMPLE,VALIDreasons for people to dislike them. But regardless, everything in one place makes sense. Sorry you're so arsed about it, but respectfully, get over it.

You'll be ok.
"

Yes, I will be okay, because I'll continue to post the reviews in a review thread, whoever starts it. And those who wish to use a giant mega thread can use it instead. As I said, it's nice to have options. People can use what they wish.

What you may consider easier may not serve others. As someone who frequently goes back to read old threads about shows from a decade or two ago, it's much easier to have them organized the way they have always been:

- A thread for show discussion after the announcement/prior to previews

- A previews thread to discuss the show as it's (in some cases, hopefully) undergoing changes.

- A reviews thread to discuss the reaction to the frozen show at opening and beyond.

It's really not that hard, and one person insisting on starting all the threads, or creating reviews threads with a bunch of superfluous nonsense as has been the case recently (if the number of people who complain about that person would simply block them it would create far less agita all around), doesn't change my opinion.

If that doesn't serve you and having everything lumped in a giant thread is best, you do you. I will do the same.

#68

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews + Reviews

Not reading all that.

Be open to change that makes users' lives easier. Maybe more would stick around. Making the experience better is a good thing, boomer.
#69

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews + Reviews

OhHiii said: "Not reading all that.

Be open to change that makes users' lives easier. Maybe more would stick around. Making the experience better is a good thing, boomer.
"

The thread police have always been the weirdest people on here. None of this matters, I promise you.

#72

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews + Reviews

CJRochester said: "I received an email today with a new discount code: FANPB2ST."

Is it struggling to fill that tiny theatre?

#73

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews + Reviews

I'm hoping we get a new cast recording. For the new orchestrations and especially for Ruthie and Leslie's performances. Fingers crossed!!!

#74

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews + Reviews

Yes, I will be okay, because I'll continue to post the reviews in a review thread, whoever starts it. And those who wish to use a giant mega thread can use it instead. As I said, it's nice to have options. People can use what they wish.

What you may consider easier may not serve others. As someone who frequently goes back to read old threads about shows from a decade or two ago, it's much easier to have them organized the way they have always been:

- A thread for show discussion after the announcement/prior to previews

- A previews thread to discuss the show as it's (in some cases, hopefully) undergoing changes.

- A reviews thread to discuss the reaction to the frozen show at opening and beyond.

It's really not that hard, and one person insisting on starting all the threads, or creating reviews threads with a bunch of superfluous nonsense as has been the case recently (if the number of people who complain about that person would simply block them it would create far less agita all around), doesn't change my opinion.

If that doesn't serve you and having everything lumped in a giant thread is best, you do you. I will do the same.
"

I agree. I look at it the same as you. To each their own.

Thanks

#75

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews + Reviews

OhHiii said: "Not reading all that.

Be open to change that makes users' lives easier. Maybe more would stick around. Making the experience better is a good thing, boomer.
"

Can't read a single post, but thinks it makes users' lives easier to lump all the posts related to a show's existence in an endless megathread instead of specific threads letting people find and read only what they want. Make it make sense.

Hall monitors don't make the experience better around here, but god knows the block function does. OhByeee.

Updated On: 11/17/26 at 09:41 PM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67