Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#26

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I think I've just found the show I'm going to see in November on my work trip. I have never liked this show, but have only seen (probably) poorly done regional theater versions.
#27

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Jordan Catalano said: "Zane’s tight shirt that highlight his huge arms and hairy chest is not my idea of emasculating, sorry. I hit arms extra hard all week, with his in mind."

Yeah. When I read the initial comment, I was like excuuuuuse me? And you are complaining why?


Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!! www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm
#28

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Jordan Catalano said: "Zane’s tight shirt that highlight his huge arms and hairy chest is not my idea of emasculating, sorry. I hit arms extra hard all week, with his in mind."

Any shirt he had on would’ve emphasized his big arms and chest. I just didn’t care for the design of the shirt. It had a delicate quality. I would’ve preferred him in a fitted black T-shirt or maybe something that leaned slightly into western wear. And I did not think the pants flattered him either. It all took me out of the play. This has nothing to do with his extreme good looks. He’s a very handsome and sexy man. I am a fan. He might have a little bit more versatility as an actor if he got rid of some of the bulk, but that’s his personal choice. And as some of you say, no one is complaining.

Updated On: 11/3/26 at 11:35 PM

#29

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I saw this yesterday afternoon and I honestly found it ridiculously charming and quaint, having not actually seen a production before. It was like opening an old music box and being charmed by the tune. If anything, my main issue was the sluggish pacing at times because, we know where the story is going, but I know Gatelli can get us there a bit faster, especially with Act II. If they tighten by 10 minutes and drop the intermission, it would be flawless for me.

Ruthie and Leslie were a HOOT - “Never Say No” felt like “Bosom Buddies” and it was enthusiastically recieved by myself and the audience. I actually really liked Zane. He was playing a role that didn’t demand he just be a sentient slab of beef and so seeing him with that kind of range was quite refreshing. The entire ensemble is really just a very tight and well assembled group.


Check out my eBay page for sales on Playbills!! www.ebay.com/usr/missvirginiahamm
#30

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

quizking101 said: "If they tighten by 10 minutes and drop the intermission, it would be flawless for me"

I think it's tough to drop the intermission for this show: it serves a crucial dramatic function à la Sunday or Into the Woods.

(To go off on a bit of a tangent, I remember reading that Sondheim took great offense when a writer for the Sondheim Review suggested that the intermission-spanning tableau of The Fantasticks was an inspiration for the structure of those two shows. Sondheim wasn't a fan of The Fantasticks and didn't care for the comparison. Some details here.)

#31

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Can anyone who's seen this recently give a rough running time?


"You travel alone because other people are only there to remind you how much that hook hurts that we all bit down on. Wait for that one day we can bite free and get back out there in space where we belong, sail back over water, over skies, into space, the hook finally out of our mouths and we wander back out there in space spawning to other planets never to return hurrah to earth and we'll look back and can't even see these lives here anymore. Only the taste of blood to remind us we ever existed. The earth is small. We're gone. We're dead. We're safe." -John Guare, Landscape of the Body
#32

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

kdogg36 said: "(To go off on a bit of a tangent, I remember reading that Sondheim took great offense when a writer for theSondheim Reviewsuggested that the intermission-spanning tableau ofThe Fantastickswas an inspiration for the structure of those two shows. Sondheim wasn't a fan ofThe Fantasticksand didn't care for the comparison. Some details here.)"

Wow, that final letter from Sondheim is quite scathing.


"I feel safe with you, and complete with you / I'm always finding money in the street with you." -Sheldon Harnick
#33

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Here now. It’s cute. But I’m very, very bored.


i went in completely blind, so not sure what I was expecting. The set is really pretty though. And the leads do have chemistry


I should’ve been Blac Chyna.
#34

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

The show just let out and I heard a guy behind me say “ OK that was way too artsy for me” and I agree. Obviously, it’s got an audience because the people around me seem to really love it, and I heard some people crying. Like this type of show is just not my cup of tea. That said, The two leads and the guy who plays the bandit are very, very, very talented. the two moms are talented as well, but to me, it was nothing to write about because I just found it corny every time they were on stage


I should’ve been Blac Chyna.
#35

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I attended the matinee this afternoon and, as someone whose first reaction to the news of this gender-swapped production was "sure, I guess?," I found myself pleasantly surprised.

I've only seen this show done once, in a university student production many years ago, so I was broadly familiar with the material but not overly so. While I'd also count myself as someone who will never be head over heels for this show, I found it to be a largely sweet diversion, and a perfectly fine way to spend an afternoon.

Both boys are quite lovely, and their performances and chemistry do a lot of the heavy lifting to make this production work. Zane Phillips is suave and sexy and had the audience in the palm of his hand, and it's always a pleasure to see Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Kritzer onstage.

I thought the design was strong across the board, from the set (which does a remarkably impressive job of filling the space while retaining and honoring the simplicity the original was known for) to the lighting to the costumes (someone please tell me WHERE I can buy the colorblock hoodie that Lewis wears in the opening). The expanded orchestrations sounded nice, as well.

Will I be thinking about it years from now? Probably not, but it sure was fun to celebrate last night's blue wave with a silly little story of queer love.

#36

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I saw it this afternoon and am still thinking about it. Firstly, for those asking, the 2pm matinee came down at 4:11.

Now, I know this show backwards so I was very aware of the changes. I found this concept to fit the show very easily and it did not need much revision to work well. But there were a few things that did bother me... I'll put this as a spoiler.

Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content

In the monologue before "Much More," the line leading into the song was "I am special. I AM special! Please, god, please... don't let me be normal!" (which is one of my favorite lines in the whole play)

Here, it ended with "Please, god, please... let me be someone special!" I hope it was just a line flub and not a scripted change.

Later before "Round And Round" the exchange between El Gallo and Louisa/Lewis is gone where they would ask, "Do I attract you?" and El Gallo replies, "...somewhat."

The "Happy Ending" of Act I the kids and parents are usually in a somewhat awkward pose (seen in the original logo) which El Gallo comments on, and wonders at their ability to hold it. Here, they're just... standing together and it kills the joke when they are struggling to maintain it at the top of Act II. Perhaps it was an issue for the performers?

All in all, it's definitely worth seeing. The performers were all very good, but Maxim Chlumecky as Matt and Ruthie Ann Miles as Lewis' Mother were truly outstanding. I'll probably go again to see how it gels over time.


"What- and quit show business?" - the guy shoveling elephant shit at the circus.
#37

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

halfhourcheckwithmerman said: "Wow, that final letter from Sondheim is quite scathing."

I agree. I'd like to think that maybe Sondheim was just having a bad day and overreacted to a comment that obviously pushed some very specific buttons. It was certainly a very hostile response to what was clearly a sincere apology.

#38

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

YvanEhtNioj said: "The show just let out and I heard a guy behind me say “ OK that was way too artsy for me” and I agree. Obviously, it’s got an audience because the people around me seem to really love it, and I heard some people crying. Like this type of show is just not my cup of tea. That said, The two leads and the guy who plays the bandit are very, very, very talented. the two moms are talented as well, but to me, it was nothing to write about because I just found it corny every time they were on stage"

Yeah, I agree with this: just not my cup of tea. I knew nothing of the music or the story going in.

The comedy is heavy on the slapstick, but obviously the audience loved it. It had Kiss Me Kate or Princess Bride vibes - especially the El Gallo, Mortimer, and Henry, but then the language wasn't consistently of that style, which was a distraction. Someone here (or Reddit) described some of the show as a fever dream, but I don't feel like the set or the lighting reflected that. At the end, I felt like I did at the Who's Tommy: very puzzled.

There were some things I liked. Try to Remember is catchy. Chlumecky has some really beautiful singing moments, as did Levy. The chemistry worked between them. I am a Ruthie Ann Miles fan, and it was nice to see her flex some comedy muscles.

Updated On: 11/5/26 at 11:53 AM

#39

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

Saw the show last week, totally going in blind. Chlumecky is a star, full of charm, a strong voice and a master of his physicality. A true star. Leslie and Ruthie were so funny and endearing. The roles did seem a little too small for their personalities (and talents) but it was clear they were enjoying the breeziness of the story, their joy was contagious. I would also say the same of Del Aguila and Kelly, they were so fun. Levy and Philips were fine, dare I say Levi was kinda just there, the role I just don't think translated well to this production.

I was mostly charmed. Until intermission was over.

Must like the show, in the light of day, it just got...weird. Which I guess is the point, but...really? And Levy and Philips big number of the second act, I feel I was the not the only one in the audience would was just, like, "Why is this going on so long?" Their chemistry just seemed so superficial. Which I guess is the point, but then again why drag it out? And then the show just ended. Okay, applause and let's go.

There were many delights - most of the performances, the sets and lights, the orchestrations and choreography. But it's hard for me to really recommend it knowing what happens after intermission.




"Hey little girls, look at all the men in shiny shirts and no wives!" - Jackie Hoffman, Xanadu, 19 Feb 2008

Updated On: 11/5/26 at 02:28 PM

#40

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I thought this was pretty damn wonderful. Gattelli's direction is masterful, and the performances are stellar. As always with this show, I find everything the two traveling actors do to be tiresome and unnecessary -- especially because the rest of the show is so wonderfully funny without pushing for it, and then they enter and I start checking my watch. But it was just such a beautiful show surrounding those bits. "Soon It's Gonna Rain" was extraordinary. As was "They Were You." And I loved the second act, sue me. I've always liked this show and never LOVED it, but something about this production made it click for me.

Ruthie and Leslie are terrific. The two boys are terrific. Zane is mostly terrific --- I thought his "It Depends On What You Pay" was pretty poor, but his "Try to Remember" was glorious.

I also think it's incredible how much Gattelli nods to the original scale and direction. The show starts with an imitation of the off-Broadway set, and then as soon as it starts it expands to a fuller Broadway set that even touches on the off-Broadway feel with an area that feels "stage"-like and an area that doesn't. The orchestrations by Sam Davis are sensational and feel similar to the set design, in that they are paying homage to the smallness and intimacy of the original production while also lovingly expanding it. They start as piano and harp, and then there is a thrilling trumpet entrance (that trick is coupled with a brilliant bit of stage business that I won't spoil). And then the very last note of the score is piano and harp again, which I found very touching.

I also appreciated that in an age of over-singing on Broadway (and I say this as someone who usually appreciates a big, loud, thrilling score!) there is a LOT of really sensitive, quiet, communicative singing being done here. Because of this, the big moments felt earned, and the small moments made me lean in. I understand that might be boring or unsatisfactory to some people, but I loved it.

I should also note that this is the best lighting in a Broadway musical I've seen in maybe a decade.

Reading this over, I'm surprised I sound so enthusiastic about a production of this show. But I find it a little bit of a miracle that this is on Broadway right now.


"I feel safe with you, and complete with you / I'm always finding money in the street with you." -Sheldon Harnick
#41

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

halfhourcheckwithmerman said: "I thought this was pretty damn wonderful. Gattelli's direction is masterful, and the performances are stellar. As always with this show, I find everything the two traveling actors do to be tiresome and unnecessary -- especially because the rest of the show is so wonderfully funny without pushing for it, and then they enter and I start checking my watch. But it was just such a beautiful show surrounding those bits. "Soon It's Gonna Rain" was extraordinary. As was "They Were You." And I loved the second act, sue me.I've always liked this show and never LOVED it, but something about this production made it click for me.

Ruthie and Leslie are terrific. The two boys are terrific. Zane is mostly terrific --- I thought his "It Depends On What You Pay" was pretty poor, but his "Try to Remember" was glorious.

I also think it's incredible how much Gattelli nods to the original scale and direction. The show starts with an imitation of the off-Broadway set, and then as soon as it starts it expands to a fuller Broadway set that even touches on the off-Broadway feel with an area that feels "stage"-like and an area that doesn't.The orchestrations by Sam Davis are sensational and feel similar to the set design, in that they are paying homage to the smallness and intimacy of the original production while also lovingly expanding it. They start as piano and harp, and then there is a thrilling trumpet entrance (that trick is coupled with a brilliant bit of stage business that I won't spoil). And then the very last note of the score is piano and harp again, which I found very touching.

I also appreciated that in an age of over-singing on Broadway (and I say this as someone who usually appreciates a big, loud, thrilling score!) there is a LOT of really sensitive, quiet, communicative singing being done here. Because of this, the big moments felt earned, and the small moments made me lean in. I understand that might be boring or unsatisfactory to some people, but I loved it.

I should also note that this is the best lighting in a Broadway musical I've seen in maybe a decade.

Reading this over, I'm surprised I sound so enthusiastic about a production of this show. But I find it a little bit of a miracle that this is on Broadway right now.
"

This was a very perceptive review! Thank you!

#42

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

This show is near and dear to my heart, having seen it in many of its incarnations (starting at Sullivan St. Playhouse in the 70s) and having had the opportunity to play Henry many years ago. While I didn’t think everything in this updated version fully worked, enough did (some of it rather brilliantly) for me to recommend it, maybe even more so if it’s your first exposure to the show. I’m completely puzzled, however, by why

Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content

they cut the last lines of the script. When the young lovers return, after the wall has been rebuilt in Act Two, one of the rejoicing fathers says “It’s a miracle, Let’s take down the wall,” and El Gallo responds: “No. Leave the wall. Remember - You must always leave the wall.” Cue the “Try to Remember” reprise and final curtain. Those lines, imparted as the closing words and moral of this fable, have always seemed to me integral to the show’s message…that “without a hurt, the heart is hollow,” and without some obstacle to happiness, we’re not capable of fully appreciating it when it comes. I realize the concept of walls has taken on some political weight, but I can’t imagine that’s the reason these key lines were cut. Thoughts?

Updated On: 11/8/26 at 05:03 PM

#43

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I saw this over the weekend after only listening to the cast recording a couple of times in high school but never seeing it live. I found it overall incredibly sweet and charming and a very well-done production on Gattelli's end.

Maxim Chlumecky is really wonderful, charming, sweet, funny, and instantly endearing. He is paired well with Levy who I saw in & Juliet and found very unimpressive, but who fares much better here. At times I wished both of their voices were a tad bit fuller -- though I saw them near the end of the week and it's entirely possible the previews schedule has resulted in a bit of vocal fatigue -- but I was ultimately really pleased with their performances. I do agree Chlumecky stands out a bit more.

Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles make a fun pair, and one I would not have expected to appear onstage together. Kritzer has tamped down a bit of the mugging, and Miles has amped up her daffiness and the result is really quite wonderful. The roles are small, but they are clearly having a great time up there, they are both in excellent voice, and they both look beautiful.

I was very impressed with Zane Phillips. I knew he would be sexy and charismatic, but I found his entire performance elevated the whole thing a bit more. He is very funny and seemed to know when to sit back and let his scene partners shine a bit more. Vocally, thought he was really stunning especially on the lower notes.

Kevin Del Aguila and David Patrick Kelly are reliable as ever, making the most of their odd little roles and having a ball together. And shoutout to Ahmad Simmons for making The Mute feel like an indispensable part of the show. He exudes joy and warmth onstage.

The production is attractive and well-designed, a sort of timeless era dropped onstage. The lighting especially I thought was beautiful.

I look forward to revisiting the show in a couple of months to see how the company has further settled into the show. But I really did have a great time.
#44

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

The musical predates me by a little, but I've loved The Fantasticks since I was a little kid. Caught the matinee today - it's a mixed bag. The direction is occasionally half-baked and other times overwrought, the pacing muddled, and the heightened dialogue is rarely met on the level required to make it work, but this is still a beautiful musical. Shockingly loses very little by being scaled up for a larger proscenium theater. There's some moments as originally written that, when placed in the context of a young gay relationship, burst with queer subtext, but these are sadly ignored instead of utilized. The highlight is Ruthie Ann Miles and Leslie Kritzer's hilarious "Never Say No" which is 2.5 of the best minutes I've had at the theater this year, though they don't fare as well in other moments, not helped by the awkward choice to slow the opening of "Plant A Radish" into something more reflective and melancholic. Echoing the thoughts of another poster, Maxim Chlumecky is an exciting new Broadway star. He is magnetic, funny, and has a beautiful command over his voice and physicality. David Patrick Kelly and Kevil Del Aguila are the other highlights of the show, and the only ones onstage who seem truly at home with the heightened language. Zane is the low point, unfortunately - he starts off the evening with a beautifully sung rendition of Try to Remember, but struggles with the fast pace of Depends on What You Pay, and from there mumbles a lot and is largely monotonous and lifeless.

#45

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I’m here at the show now, intermission. This is boring as $hit other than a few amusing moments from the two ladies and Kevin Del Aquila and David Patrick Kelly. They also sound horrible, nobody in the cast is in good voice, most of them can’t sing at all. Zane Phillips can’t act or sing. It’s all boring empty treats for the audience.

Updated On: 11/14/26 at 09:12 PM

#46

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

getatme said: "I saw this over the weekend after only listening to the cast recording a couple of times in high school but never seeing it live. I found it overall incredibly sweet and charming and a very well-done production on Gattelli's end.

Maxim Chlumecky is really wonderful, charming, sweet, funny, and instantly endearing. He is paired well with Levy who I saw in & Juliet and found very unimpressive, but who fares much better here. At times I wished both of their voices were a tad bit fuller -- though I saw them near the end of the week and it's entirely possible the previews schedule has resulted in a bit of vocal fatigue -- but I was ultimately really pleased with their performances. I do agree Chlumecky stands out a bit more.

Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles make a fun pair, and one I would not have expected to appear onstage together. Kritzer has tamped down a bit of the mugging, and Miles has amped up her daffiness and the result is really quite wonderful. The roles are small, but they are clearly having a great time up there, they are both in excellent voice, and they both look beautiful.

I was very impressed with Zane Phillips. I knew he would be sexy and charismatic, but I found his entire performance elevated the whole thing a bit more. He is very funny and seemed to know when to sit back and let his scene partners shine a bit more. Vocally, thought he was really stunning especially on the lower notes.

Kevin Del Aguila and David Patrick Kelly are reliable as ever, making the most of their odd little roles and having a ball together. And shoutout to Ahmad Simmons for making The Mute feel like an indispensable part of the show. He exudes joy and warmth onstage.

The production is attractive and well-designed, a sort of timeless era dropped onstage. The lighting especially I thought was beautiful.

I look forward to revisiting the show in a couple of months to see how the company has further settled into the show. But I really did have a great time.
"

Bless your heart thinking the show is gonna last months. lol

#47

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

It’s non-profit theatre, so yeah. It will run for a few months as announced.

#48

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

It has commercial producers attached, maybe their goal is an Appropriate type of situation with a transfer somewhere? Or a commercial off broadway run?


i actually wish this was a hetero story. If you’re going to gay it up, GO FOR IT. I was watching this wanting the young guys to mount Zane Phillips when they’re trying to experience life. The whole thing flirts with queer but doesn’t lean into it. It stays in this vanilla family friendly place. The story is antithetical to queer folk anyway who often NEED to leave their home towns and COME ALIVE out in the big bad city. The whole show is just a cute little skit. Nothing less, nothing more. It has none of the beauty and depth of Maybe Happy Ending or Into the Woods. It’s just a mildly amusing, mildly charming evening, not worth it if you’re trying to save money or have limited time.

#49

Re: THE FANTASTICKS Previews

I saw this again today and loved it even more than I did the first time. I think it’s just an absolutely perfect production and everybody’s performances have gotten so much stronger since the first preview. Just a remarkably special show that I hope everybody gets a chance to see.

Latest Posts

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71