So, I saw it last night and thought I'd share some of my musings. First, let me say that the cast is really doing the very best they can with the material they have been given. I will say that there are noticable differences in the technique of the dancers' abilities. This is most apparent with the female cast members when you see some of them pointing their toes and others apparently unable to do so. The male cast members are more consistently outstanding. Michael Andrew does a fantastic job of bringing life to the dual role of Julius/Buddy. Each character is completely distinct to the point that sometimes it is hard to believe that the same actor is playing both roles. The set is pretty cool for a pre-Broadway tryout in a smaller venue. The lack of automation is noticable, as actors are pushing the set pieces around by hand.
Now, the real problem with the show is the book and lyrics. The music is fun, but not at all memorable. Some of the jokes are quite funny, while many land with a thud. It is almost as if you are watching a revival of a 1960's show. It's a new show, but immediately feels dated. If you were not a fan of Jerry Lewis and the comedy of the 1960's, much of the humor might go over your head. One example is the gym manager who is a direct hommage to Jack LaLanne. If you don't know who Jack LaLanne was, then you're likely going to miss quite a bit of the humor in this show. There was a completely boring, long production number with cheerleaders and band majors that really did nothing to advance the story. It looked like the casts of "Bring It On" and "Legally Blonde" were sort of passing through the theatre on the way to their shows. The whole teacher-student romance was a bit creepy in today's culture. The character of Stella started off strong, but became uninteresting as the show progressed. Ms. Lemmon went the other way and finished strongly. I could go on and on, but I'll spare you all the details.
They are going to need to rework the show substantially if they don't want to be laughed off Broadway. I really wanted to like it, and there were several parts that I did like, but it's just not there yet.
The direction wasn't terrible, but it wasn't great, either. Apparently, Mr. Lewis thinks that every time a leading actor has to deliver a solo, duet, or monologue they have to do it downstage center. It really got tiring. It is possible to be in focus and not be in the downstage center spotlight. The choreography was servicable, but not great.
They did not provide any opportunity for audience feedback. No surveys, no talkbacks, nothing. For a show that is trying for Broadway, I felt like they should have had something to measure the audience's reaction to the show. I wish I could sit down with Mr. Lewis for about an hour. I really do have some thoughts about how they could improve the show, but unfortunately they didn't seem interested in feedback. I hope that sort of vanity is not going to doom this show for good.
Updated On: 8/13/12 at 09:21 AM