I saw the show on Wednesday evening and really enjoyed it! I'll echo the below sentiments that this is an intimate and introspective musical without much in terms of plot. The true star of the show is David Yazbek's score, which I loved. The whimsy he's well known for from his previous musicals is on full display in songs like "Welcome to Nowhere," "Beat of Your Heart," and "Papi Hears the Ocean," but they're balanced with some beautiful and soaring ballads like "Omar Sharif," "Something Different," and "Answer Me." Does anyone associated with or tangentially connected to the production know if they're planning on recording the score with this cast? I really hope they do!
They've assembled a great cast for this production, but Katrina Lenk is the standout of the bunch. She's delivering a funny, sad, sexy, and mysterious performance and she nails the humorous frustration ("It Is What It Is"
and the emotional moments equally well. I also particularly enjoyed Tony Shalhoub and Daniel David Stewart. I like Scott Pask's set design a lot and thought it was very impressive and expansive for the size of the Linda Gross Theater. Itamar Moses' book is mostly well-written and well-paced, although I think he glosses over some of the story arcs for some of the characters that I think could be fleshed out. I also very much appreciated David Cromer's direction and never thought the show felt disjointed even though it continuously moves from character to character. Cromer did speak to the audience before the show and cautioned that they had reworked at least 30 minutes of material that afternoon alone, so I think they've making a lot of changes to the show as they go through the preview process. Had he not mentioned it, though, nobody would have noticed because the performance went off without a hitch.
After this limited run at the Atlantic, does anybody know if they have their sights on Broadway in the 2017-2018 season? It seems like they've assembled too many sizable talents to let the show collect dust after they workshop it here. As I said about a cast recording, I hope they do plan to transfer the show next season. I was so taken by the score, the performances, and the overall production that I'd love to see it again and would love for a wider audience to see it, too.