Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

The Sondheim Hub: What's To Discuss, Old Friends?

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#4

Re: The Sondheim Hub: What's To Discuss, Old Friends?

Makes me wonder how the fictional characters fared over the years.

How do we imagine the 80s and beyond went for the main three, Mary, Franklin, and Charlie?

Did Franklin and Charlie ever reconcile? Did Mary ever recover from her alcoholism? Was there ever an Encores! production of Musical Husbands?


Beyoncé is not an ally. Actions speak louder than words, Mrs. Carter. #Dubai #$$$
#5

Re: The Sondheim Hub: What's To Discuss, Old Friends?

I was able to exchange a few words with Daniel Radcliffe at the Merrily stage door. I asked him if he thought Charlie would be okay, and his response was basically, "He's only 40, and he has a good marriage and kids. He'll be fine." And even for Mary and Frank, they're only 40, and they do have an opportunity to turn their lives around.

My charitable reading of Mary is that she was having one of the lowest nights of her life when we see her at Frank's party. Does she need to lay off the alcohol? Definitely. But there's an eternal optimist in me that wants to think that something could have changed.
#6

Re: The Sondheim Hub: What's To Discuss, Old Friends?

Maybe this is me nitpicking, but the one thing that's always sort of bothered me about that "one bad night" is the acid attack that ends it. That is SUCH a huge, macabre and melodramatic swing that it comes out of nowhere, and almost nothing in the show that follows leans that wildly towards melodrama, so it feels like a slightly unearned or unwarranted moment. Like we begin the show briefly in Beyond the Valley of the Dolls but then spend no time there.
#7

Re: The Sondheim Hub: What's To Discuss, Old Friends?

Charlie had the greatest likelihood of recovering and living a meaningful life. He's a playwright (though it isn't clear if he's had any successes apart from his collaboration with Frank), and as Radcliffe rightly noted, he's well-grounded in his personal life (he also seems to have basic common sense).

But Mary has basically no hope. She's a drunk, her life is empty, and although it's just possible she's finally woken up from the fantasy world of hanging on to Frank somehow, I don't think the show gives any indication she has that sort of inner strength.

Frank actually isn't a failure, he just isn't likable. The first incarnation of the musical suggests he was now washed up, since his big movie is apparently a big bomb, but later productions have made him a still successful producer. Nor does he have any addiction issues preying on him. He probably won't ever be able to really commit to anyone, and he likely will always put the dollar first. But if that's some big tragedy, I'm missing it.

Really, the show just doesn't make sense--didn't make sense in its older, hectoring, moralistic version, doesn't make sense in its more even-handed revisions. Of the characters, only Charlie is given believable motivations for why he acts as he acts. And none of them are well-developed.

But it's got a gorgeous, tuneful score, and the show works emotionally.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $67