I just got home from the show tonight and found the piece to be marvelously presented, but it is supremely sinister, chilling and a solemn indictment of humankind. Doyle's brechtian direction is some of the best of the season; it rightfully adds to the bleakness of the situation and enhances the social commentary, but it's not going to help the show be any easy sell.
Chita is very self-assured and at ease with Claire, commanding the stage from her entrance to her final exit. It's not an overly flashy role; she does more striking a pose in her majestic white coat with her cane than most would by breaking a sweat running around a stage.
Roger Rees acts the role beautifully, but his singing left a little to be desired. Some sour notes came out here and there. Still, I thought his dramatic performance mostly compensated for his vocal inadequacies.
Mary Beth Peil is, as always, a most welcome presence on the stage. Jason Danieley sang his big number beautifully. Chita's entourage (without spoiling who they are) were especially delightfully.
I will say I think the less you know about the plot going in, the better. It's a mystery that slowly unravels, so even though you know something sinister is afoot from the beginning, what she actually has in store for the town is surprising.
The score is strong and very catchy, but don't go in expecting big numbers or defined applause breaks. Most of the songs just kind of ebb and flow in and out of the dialogue- it's like the piece is one giant bench scene.
The scenic design is beautiful and immediately impressive upon entering the theater.
Really not enough good can be said about Doyle's direction. This, Sher's King and I, Gold's Fun Home and Nicholaw's Something Rotten! will make for one of the toughest categories is recent Tony memory. We really have some wonderful talent directing musicals this season.
Sadly, I think this could struggle to find an audience. As Roger Debris would say, "It's too downbeat!" The balcony was sadly about half empty tonight. I do wish the show the best and will absolutely be making some return visits to the Lyceum soon.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!
