Whether the production is overhauled or not, I just really don't see this catching on as a "moderate hit or better". In order to recoup on Broadway, it will need to be a success with locals and tourists which, given the source material on which it's based, is not very likely (Smaxie - that is why I mentioned the show's odd elements, which are rooted in the material, not the production, and difficult to overcome).
Now, I don't have any ill-will towards the show. I just don't see how a profitable run could be conjured out of it. Perhaps with the right star, the right marketing campaign, unbelievable timing, lack of competition, and magic lamp, it could be a remote possibility. I did enjoy it more than the over-produced Spider Woman, but then, the only thing I enjoyed about the original production of Spider Woman was the score, so who knows? Maybe The Visit will sweep the Tonys! Still not an indicator of financial success, though.
Brody Fosse - You are so correct! Reinking's "choreography" to Bye Bye Birdie was ghastly-to-nonexistent. It was the worst element of the entire production and an embarrassment.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian