hork said: "Lots of shows get dumped on whenever they're mentioned, and more pervasively than Hamilton: The Lion King, Cats, Rent, Memphis, et al. Why should Hamilton be immune?"
Because more often than not, the criticism Hamilton is slung on here stems less from actual subjective artistic perspective and more from resentment/bitterness of the show's swelling juggernaut/phenom status. Don't remember where, but I read a thread featuring somebody who was pissed simply because he/she saw a Hamilton sign on a city bus. I'm not saying Hamilton should be "immune," I'm saying that when it's denunciated on here, it's often for unfounded reasons.