I'm not a fan of Footloose. I think the book is poorly written and if it weren't for the title song everyone knows, I think everyone would bash on the score. I feel like the plot is too muddy. You have too many things going in at the same time. You have Ren being a new kid, Ren missing his dad, dancing is a sin, dancing is a crime, the town is religious, Ariel falls in love with him, the town is shaken up by the death of the brother, etc.
I just think there are so many elements that aren't clarified well. Like Ren was dancing and it was a crime, so why didn't he get in trouble with the law? It's very ambiguous because it's both a sin and a law. And I don't think it makes sense that Reverend Shaw as a minister would change his mind so easily considering it's a sin. Laws are easily changed. The definition of sin to a preacher is not something you can change just because a kid made you realize you have to get over the death of your son. I hope that made sense.
So what is it? Is it a drama about religion? Is it a romance? Is it just a big musical about dancing? It doesn't do any of those well. Sorry. Not sorry.
Not only that but the book has lines that are so plastic and fake. I don't think anyone naturally would say some of those lines. Can I also bring up the song "Mama Says"?? That song is the equivalent to a fart joke in musical theatre. The lyrics are so dumb and it's an awful song for a cheap laugh. I love all kinds of theatre and music, but this is just distasteful.