Let me first say I am not one of those people who use bots and buy up huge blocks of tickets. I'm just a single guy who was aggressive when the blocks of Hamilton tickets went on sale. As a result I have four tickets on the aisle second row of the orchestra for one night and two tickets third row aisle seats in the front mezzanine for another night.
Those tickets are mine. I paid for them. With my credit card. They belong to me. What I do with them is now up to me.
If I choose to use them to go see the show (which I won't. I hated it when I saw it.) that's great because they belong to me. If I give them to friends or family members to use (which I won't. I wouldn't subject anyone I care about to it) that's my business because they are tickets that I paid for. If I choose to set them on fire with my cigarette lighter that is also my business because they are my tickets.
If I choose to resell them (which I do) that is also my business. They are my tickets. What I ask for them is up to me. They are my tickets.
If you pay me what I ask for them they will be your tickets. Until that time they will remain my tickets to do with as I please. If they go unoccupied because no one wants to pay me my asking price that's also my business. I'm not asking you to pay my credit card bill so don't worry about whether I make my money back or not.
And please don't tell me I should have let people who really want to see the show get them. I didn't do anything magical or high tech. I signed on when they went on sale and bought them. Six tickets all together over two different performances. Not 600.
You could've done the same thing and then they would have been your tickets to do with as you like. But you didn't. I did and they are now my tickets.