Now I'm jealous that I attended the second-to-last performance of Spring Awakening, where all that song got was a standing O that went on for 3 minutes. The church bells finally shut them up.
I hear the song got a standing O, and an encore that was only planned for this performance. I bet there were many SA fans and "guilty ones" alike, singing along from the audience during that part. Did you get the feeling that it was planned or impromptu?
(As a side note: There were four curtain calls when I saw the second-to-last performance, and it wasn't even the last! That was unprecedented!)
"How could she just suddenly, completely disappear into thin water?" - The Little Mermaid