I just got back from seeing today's sold-out matinee of UP HERE at the La Jolla Playhouse. I will say that I'm 27 years old and was one of five people under 50 at this performance and I seemed to enjoy it much more than a lot of the older folks (shocker - I know). There are spoilers below so read on at your own peril.
It's definitely an entertaining show with a solid score, but there is a lot of eccentricity and some things that I'm sure will be changing as the work is further developed.
It is one of the most colorful shows I've seen in a while, definitely visually impressive - major props to the Lighting Designer David Weiner.
The most tuneful, hummable song in the show is the opening number which is also the title.
There are a lot of themes relating to romance and the way we view ourselves throughout the whole show.
There is a "B" plot involving a rock and a child that seems random, and even when it "pays off" it feels unnecessary.
There is a song in the first act that just, I can't get the image out of my head. It's a country-esque number that features tapping miners and dancing cacti (that'd be the plural of cactus). It's the most ridiculous thing I've ever seen on a stage - and that's kind of the tone of the whole piece. In some instances it really works, but in others it feels pretty off the mark.
The acting was uniformly excellent. The lead characters played exceptionally well by Betsy Wolfe and Matt Bittner feel pretty developed so it does feel like a show well on its way. Bittner's character - Dan - is the one whose thoughts - via varied characters - come to life onstage. There are four main "demons" of his consciousness that recur and they are all portrayed with great humor, but a sense of reality.
Alex Timbers' staging was spectacular - the man knows how to put on a show. There is a song in the second act where they bring up a random audience member and both leads sing at her and even improv a bit and everyone in the theater was cracking up throughout that song.
If you're in LA or the area and can get tickets, I'd recommend going. There is some work to do, but it's a completely original musical romantic comedy that will leave you feeling good. I'm sure it will be Broadway-bound in the next two or so years.