Visiting NYC - show suggestions

I will be in NYC the first week in June for my tri-annual NYC Theater trip (last visit was in January 2011). I thought I had all my slots filled, but I think I may pass on House of Blue Leaves and (possibly) IHO at the Public. I thought House would be absurdist humor but sounds kind of dull and IHO just seems like an excruciating marathon.

I am seeing:

Sister Act
Book of Mormon
Anything Goes
Catch Me if you Can
War Horse
Priscilla
Normal Heart

From my prior NYC trips, I have seen almost everything (aside from those listed for this trip) and possibly have 2 slots to fill from the following list:

Jerusalem (not very hyped about this one)
Bengal Tiger (ditto on the not hyped)
M***f with the Hat
Importance of Being Ernest
Good People (would LOVE to see this but it will be closed before I get there)

I have seen pretty much everything else on Broadway. Other options would be something off-Bway (like the Sleep No More). Any suggestions? Or - does anyone want to talk me into liking IHO despite the wildly divergent opinions on this site and on NYTimes site?

PS - I also have tickets for People in the Picture (passing on that) and Wonderland (passing on that as well). And before anyone wonders how I can pass on shows I paid good $$$ for, I prefer to enjoy my vacation. Dont usually blow off this many shows, but this year was quite unusual in that way.

Thanks in advance for any opinions.

I just saw Motherf**cker with the Hat and loved it. Bobby Cannavale was incredible.

---

I'm partial to Jerusalem. I thought it was fantastic.

---

SLEEP NO MORE. Sorry for the all-caps, but this show warrants it! It's unique, it's wonderful, it's like being in an interactive dream world for 3 hours. I still dream about it.

I hve been hearing a lot of people rave about "Sleep No More". I would also suggest "And By the Way, Meet Vera Stark". I wasn't crazy about Act II but it is a good play. I would also suggest Motherf**ker With The Hat. Loved it. Born Yesterday was a lot of fun also.

---

I am in the same situation.. Hit NYC 4 or 5 times a year... and see most of the shows.. I will also be in town first week of June and was last in town April.
In April I had tickets to People in the Picture and was going to skip out on it, but ended up staying an extra day and went and saw it.. I really enjoyed it. It is not perfect theater, but I really do think its worth seeing. Donna Murphys performance alone is worth seeing.
I also really like Vera Stark and I really enjoyed it!