Young Frankenstien kicked out The Pirate Queen.
Miss Saigon bumped Les Misérables to the Imperial
And if I remember correctly, The Act bumped the Wiz to the Broadway.
West Side Story is a bankable title, hasn't had a revival in almost 30 years, and is being directed by Arthur Laurents, if it wanted the Shubert it could probably get it.
http://www.youtube.com/huskcharmer