"I, personally, just think Albin is being an ass."
I think all three of you are being asses. If Streisand would agree to do the role, it would be a major casting coup. She's the right age and she can sing the ass off pretty much anybody else who's been suggested.
Dollypop's complaints about Streisand break down to; 1) She was the wrong age. 2) She didn't have any chemistry with Walter Mattheau (sp) and 3) She played Dolly as Jewish although Dolly is written as an Irishwoman who married a Jewish man.
oh, and 4) She got the movie role and Channing didn't.
1) Streisand is the right age now.
2) I don't think anybody short of Jack Lemmon has ever had any chemistry with Walter Mattheau.
3) Pearl Bailey played her as a [black] woman! I don't hear anybody complaining about that!
and finally;
4) At the risk of being bitch-slapped, Carol Channing's forte was live theatre. Blown up on a 40 foot screen, she would have been w a y too broad! The producers never wanted her for the movie (the mind shuts down at the idea of Elizabeth Taylor as Dolly, but there it is)
There are problems with the movie. (Never get a dancer to direct- were the musical numbers that long on stage?) But it is an enjoyable production.
"Now and then life hits you on the back of the head with a sock full of wet porridge. How you handle that is up to you." - Tim Rice