ggersten said: "joevitus said: "Well, to be fair, "What I Did for Love" is clearly a song meant to sound like a love song. It was a push to get a hit (they got it), and it feels forced into its place onstage, so I'm not surprised they tried it as a love song in the move. Not to defend the movie (which is garbage) or criticize the stage show(which is genius), but that song is shoe-horned in,in a way none of the other numbers are."
Many years ago (like 1981 or so) I asked Hamlisch this exact question about the song feeling forced in. He said that he had to beg Bennett to leave "What I Did For Love" in the show for precisely thereason you stated. I recall he said that he told Bennett "You've got to let me have one hit". I may have the edited interview on a cassette tape somewhere.
"
I can believe it. Would love to hear that tape.