What should we see (Labor Day Weekend edition)?

Have 3 open slots, for B'way or Off B'way:

Saturday Matinee
Saturday Night
Sunday Matinee

Prefer not to spend retail price, if possible, I'm not seeing much in the way of quality seating on the discounts, though.

A little about us:

Favorite non-huge Musical of last 10 years: Urinetown
Favorite non-huge Play of last 10 years: Lieutenant of Inishmore (duh)

Loved Hand to God earlier this year, as well as An Iliad, so our likes are quite varied.

TDF member, but not much is listed (yet) for that weekend that intrigues us, other than Cock (first joke in is allowed, after that you're just being repetitive).


We've already seen all the long running shows

All things being equal we'd like to see on B'way: Best Man, One Man/Two Guvners, and I guess Once. Off B'way we'd like to see Old Jews Telling Jokes, but I bet there's something else out there for us as well.

Suggest away!

From your affinity profile, I can almost guarantee that if you miss One Man, Two Guvnors, you would be very unhappy.

Urinetown is also my favorite show few know about, and I loved One Man (not at U'town's level, but not many shows are). Two people whose tastes match mine pretty well have very strongly recommended Old Jews Telling Jokes to me. I'm not sure Best Man (which I enjoyed but I'm a political wonk) fits in with your show profile all that well. Once is my fav show running right now, but I'm not sure how much under list you'll get it.
This wasn't near as helpful as I hoped it might be when I started typing, sorry 'bout that

I loved One Man, and really enjoyed Once and Best Man, so you can't go wrong with any of those. I too loved and recommend Peter and the Starcatcher.

---

Thank you for all the advice.

I absolutely hate most farce (Noises Off is by far my least enjoyed show ever), but I do like British farce (more Python, please!), so Guvners is definitely on the list. Broadway Box doesn't have much good for that, Best Man, or Once, though.


Already seen Clybourne Park, great recommendation from here from our last trip to NYC.


I know nothing about Tribes.