What to see...

I am going into the city on Wednesday and already have tickets to Talley's Folly. I am trying to figure out what to see for the evening show. Below is a list of what I've seen. I am truly open to anything, just want to see something good. Thank you for your help.

Annie, Book of Mormon, Chicago, Jersey Boys, Lion King, Mamma Mia, Matilda, Edwin Drood, Newsies, Once, Phantom, Spiderman, Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike, Wicked

Avenue Q, Blue Man Group, Fantasticks, Forbidden Broadway, Madrid, Perfect Crime

And I have tickets to a later performance of Last 5 Years.

Kinky Boots

---

The OP has already seen Matilda. If you are going to stick around, you really need to actually read the posts.

---

If you're open to seeing another play that day, as opposed to a musical (you've already seen so many!), I would recommend All in the Timing at 59E59. I loved it so much, I'm going back to see it again this weekend. Made up of six one-act plays, the show is so so funny, and brilliantly performed and staged. I would describe it as Monty Python on a good day with an extra dose of absurdism thrown in. Nice small theater too.

Thank you everyone for your suggestions. I really appreciate it.