Thanks to the original production of Annie, Hairspray, and the revival of Ragtime, that honor goes to the Neil Simon (formerly, the Alvin) Theatre.
City Center Encores Series. Been a subscriber since season 2. So since 1995 and they do 3 a season plus the I think 3 summer ones. Rough math about 50 different shows give or take.
But technically not Broadway so if it doesn't count disregard. lol
Offhand, I'm pretty sure mine is the Hirschfeld/Beck, the Neil Simon, or the Marquis...I honestly can't remember though I'm pretty sure I've seen upwards of 6 shows in all three of those.
Al Hirschfeld(Martin Beck) with 8 shows.
Marquis with 6-
A lot of the others I've seen at least 4 shows.
Broadway Star Joined: 10/27/07
Tie Between:
Hirschfeld (Curtains, Hair)
Booth (Faith Healer, Next to Normal)
Jacobs (Frost/Nixon, God of Carnage)
Longacre (Boeing Boeing, La Cage)
Shubert (Spamalot, Blithe Spirit)
St. James (Gypsy, American Idiot)
Studio 54 (Sunday in the Park, Waiting for Godot)
Barrymore- Company, Speed-the-Plow, Race, Arcadia
For me, it's a two way tie between The Hirschfield/Martin Beck and the St. James, both four shows each. At the Hirschfeild, I have seen (in order) Man Of La Mancha, The Wedding Singer, Curtains and Hair.
At The St. James, it has been (also in order) The Producers, Gypsy, Finian's Rainbow and American Idiot.
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/11/10
Tie between the Shubert and Neil Simon at 4 each.
Shubert: Gypsy (Bernadette revival), Spamalot, Blithe Spirit, Memphis
Neil Simon: The King & I (my first bway show), The Music Man, Ragtime, Catch Me If You Can
double
Updated On: 4/4/11 at 11:46 PM
Marquis: 5 - WONDERLAND (twice), White Christmas (Errico cast), White Christmas (original), Woman in White, Annie Get Your Gun
Understudy Joined: 9/5/08
Eugene O'neill
Five guys named Moe (my B'way first show)
Caroline, or Change
Sweeney Todd
Spring Awakening
Fela
Book of Mormon
Swing Joined: 3/28/11
Al Hirschfeld (Martin Beck) with 6:
Curtains
Sweet Charity
Wedding Singer
Wonderful Town (Donna Murphy)
Man of La Mancha (Brian Stokes Mitchell)
Sweet Smell of Success
(How to Succeed on April 26 will make it 7)
Three-way tie for second place:
Marquis (5): Come Fly Away; La Cage aux Folles; The Drowsy Chaperone; The Woman in White; Thoroughly Modern Millie; (Wonderland on April 27 will make 6)
Studio 54 (5): Assassins; Sondheim on Sondheim; The Ritz; Threepenny Opera; Cabaret; (People in the Picture on April 23 will make it 6)
Walter Kerr (5): A Catered Affair; A Little Night Music; Doubt; Grey Gardens; Take Me Out (House of Blue Leaves on April 25 will make it 6)
Like a lot of other folks, mine is the Hirschfeld (Wedding Singer, Hair, Elf, How to Succeed). The Broadhurst will tie it when I see Baby, It's You later this month (Aspects of Love, Kiss of the Spider Woman, Into the Woods).
Al Hirschfield with 3 (How to Succeed, A tale of two cities and Hair).
In the West End it is the Novello with 6 (Spring Awakening, Drowsy Chaperone, Betty Blue Eyes, An Inspector Calls, Onassis and Cat on a Hot Tin Roof).
Al Hirschfield with 9:
The Rink
Grand Hotel
Kiss Me Kate
Wonderful Town
The Wedding Singer
Curtains
A Tale of Two Cities
Hair
How to Succeed
Runner up - the Walter Kerr with 8:
Love! Valor! Compassion!
Waiting in the Wings
Take Me Out
Doubt
Grey Gardens
A Catered Affair
A Little Night Music (Zeta-Jones)
A Little Night Music (Peters)
Mine is the Marriott with 4 (in order): Thoroughly Modern Millie (the night I discovered who Sutton Foster is), The Drowsy Chaperone, White Christmas and Wonderland.
That theatre holds my fondest memories, too. It changed my life, as cheesy as that may sound. But I now I can't help but to smile when I walk in that theatre! :)
The Lunt-Fontanne. Beauty and the Beast, The Little Mermaid, and The Addams Family.
Add me to the the Hirschfeld! 4 times: Wedding Singer, Curtains, Hair, H2$.
Tied for 2nd (a bunch of 3 times):
Jacobs: God of Carnage, BBAJ, That Championship Season
Neil Simon: Hairspray, Ragtime (Revival), CMIYC
Ford Center/ Hilton/ Foxwoods: 42nd Street, Young Frankenstein, Spiderman
Richard Rodgers: Seussical, Tarzan, In the Heights
The Palace Theatre - Aida, Vanessa Williams Silver and Gold Christmas Show and West Side Story.
Videos