Philly03, I actually agree with some of your viewpoints on the show. It needs work, a lot in some areas. However, I just disagree with your broad interpretation of press reviews. That same review that you reference starts out “Wonderland is better” and “Wonderland is back, and it's bigger and brighter and more boffo than ever. Many of the changes made to the musical based on Alice's Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking-Glass are definite improvements, as it prepares to bow on Broadway in April.”
My point, saying the show received “worse reviews in Tampa in January '11 than it did in '09” is not accurate, but more of a reflection of your personal views. To be frank, there are hardly any reputable reviews to reference from the January '11 incarnation, and the one you do reference says it improved but with many caveats.
Secondly, thanks for pointing out that Ritchie tweeted the new script “was funny,” but to me, that’s not enough to say “the new script for Broadway is much funnier than the '11 Tampa production.”
I truly enjoy reading your assessment of shows. However, I think we all need to be careful about making broad statements about general perception in the press or future show direction, some of which may be colored with our own personal viewpoint.
Enjoy the new Broadway version.
Updated On: 3/6/11 at 08:43 AM