I drove out with my father and a friend to see the first preview (They were offering pay as you can tickets) And the drive wasn't bad at all, around two hours in total from Manhattan.
The show itself was phenomenal, with both York and Buckley giving truly remarkable performances. Before the show started the director came out and informed us that it was actually the first time they would be performing the entire show, and they had someone on script and were prepared to use the "God mic" to halt the show if they felt like something was unsafe for an actor. Despite this warning, the show went off practically without a hitch, the only flub being played off in character and without the need to call for a line.
Rachel York does an incredible job with what I consider the hardest role in the show, being able to pull of the transformation from the first act to the second. Her Around the World had me in tears, as did her Another Winter in a Summer Town. She truly makes you feel for Little Edie, and as you watch her be unable to escape Grey Gardens, you can feel the audience's heartbreak.
As Big Edie, Buckley is perfectly nailing the character, making it feel like the real Big Edie actually walked on stage. And her voice, my goodness! From The Cake I Had to Jerry Likes my Corn, she nails both the comedy and sadness. Simply fantastic, her performance in the second act alone was well worth the drive out.
As well as York and Buckley, the supporting cast was supremely strong. Matt Doyle as Joseph P. Kennedy, Jr/Jerry was fantastic, with some very strong singing in Goin' Places. This role gave him a chance to show of his strong acting talent as well, which is superb!
Sarah Hunt as young Edie was the biggest surprise of the show for me. She is a phenomenal young actress, and I hope to see more of her in New York soon.
Lastly, I really enjoyed what Bay Street has done with the staging, it is very intimate and makes good use of space on the sides to give the illusion of the house.