For sentemental reasons, the Majestic for me is my Fav. even if phantom wasnt there it is still a great house.
My other fav is the Winter Garden, I've never seen cats in there, but when i went to Mamma Mia it was so nice and "clean" looking, pluss it is strange looking because it is so wide.
The New Am certainly is the prettiest.
Hated the Nederlander, Imperial and Broadway.
Cant wait to see how the Minskoff looks now that Disney threw up all over it.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/27199361@N08/ Phantom at the Royal Empire Theatre