A show is considered a flop if it closed at a loss. It's merely a financial term. Despite winning several Tonys and running for a few years, THOROUGHLY MODERN MILLIE was a flop.
Favorite that I never saw: MACK & MABLE
That I did see: TABOO
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/11/06
Seussical was indeed a flop. ITW wasn't I guess but I wasn't sure.
And No, Jay Johnson was not meant to be experimental. It was planning to run at least a year or two.
1. The Golden Apple
2. Carrie
3. Henry Sweet Henry
Those who keep saying CARRIE, do you know the show?
It is and was horrible!
The Woman In White
followed by:
Carrie!
Anyone Can Whistle
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/13/05
The Woman in White...for sure.
All_for_Laura and I should start a club. :)
Mack and Mabel
Aspects of Love (yeah, yeah, I know...)
I looooove Henry Sweet Henry and The Human Comedy and Mack and Mabel and Baby and Oh, Brother! and The Rink and Smile and so many more...
I was fortunate to have seen CARRIE in May 1988, so yes...I know how the show is and was. It was simply sensational and horrible at the same time and the audience LOVED it -- for all the good and bad reasons. Just by the way they had the entire auditorium painted pitch black, you knew this was going to be a fun ride. And it was.
The Carrie/Margaret White moments stood out as sheer gems in this mess, but the rest was just a lot of campy fun -- like "Do Me a Favor" and of course, Charlotte (d'Amboises)'s masterpiece: "Out for Blood" which was hard to watch with your mouth closed. It was one of those classic "what the fu*k?!" moments in life.
The show was doing SRO during previews, so it WAS selling tickets (Betty Buckley even confirmed this). Due to the horrid reviews, the novice German producers panicked and decided to close the show quickly. They could have run for a few more months just by the advance in ticket sales alone.
Too late and too bad.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/11/06
Add Sweet Smell of Success.
Was The Full Monty a flop?
Lennon and Chess!
Stand-by Joined: 10/26/06
Sweeney revival recouped in record time so it is not a flop by that standard.
Was Pimpernel a flop? It lasted long enough for me to see it twice so it must have played for a while.
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/29/06
The Woman in White and.. I hate to say it, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (I don't believe it ever recouped)
Thankstophantom, we are totally co-presidents!
Sunday in the Park with George
Videos