I was wrong about this Broadway Phantom, MOTN was performed with just as much emotion as The Movie's Phantom. I cried (that and because my husband was driving around looking for our hotel and missing the whole show) during all his songs (Howard McGillin's) His acting and emotions, passion was exhausting.
How can he do that every night? PONR was not sensual but comical mostly until the end. But that is the show.
You should see it. A great talent. I think the papers say he is 50+? My husband and I cannot imagine him older than 36! Of course, he did have makeup smeared across his face, (which is a great moisurizer every night)!
I told him it must be the Irish passion. (I did not mention Butler being Irish, for to put his voice near the level of his own would be an insult, if interpreted that way. But of course, the beauty in one voice may be different than the appeal in another)
What ALW did give us in Butler was the most expressive set of eyes I have seen in any actor going back to the first generation of fine gentlemen actors. And if we are to see the Phantom associated with ALW's music up close, we would want to see exactly that, the most expressive eyes that can move your emotions from one feeling to another in a split second.
Another thing is the rock voice: and this is only personal. The music is slower for Butler to sing it. In a deep voice, sometimes only speaking quivering, whispering. These are things that any man with a deep voice can do if he tries.
Singing to the Cast recording is near impossible for my husband.
But, he lures me with his deep whispers of MOTN from the movie soundtrack that he plays over again and again in his car to master the words... to gain mastery over me

.....with that beautiful music.
Music is powerful. A strong, romantic, loving bond is powerful to keep a marriage strong to keep a family strong.
To realise this is wisdom.