I was there last night as well, and it was my first time seeing the show. I'm pretty much going to echo everything that Jaxel said.
de'Adre Aziza did quite well last night in a role and show that just doesn't live up to any of the incredibly talented people on that stage. I love Sherie Rene Scott, but frankly, de'Adre seems more appropriate in the role. You could tell the cast was extremely supportive of her last night. There were lots of whoops and cheers backstage before and after act 1, and they all gave her a really nice hand at her bow.
I think the biggest problem for me last night was that I was bored, except when Laura Benanti was onstage. I'm agreeing with everyone who says she steals the show completely. She has the best material in the show, and she runs with it.
The other problem was thinking to myself of all those great actors on that stage who have played such great, iconic roles who are now reduced to doing this. To think that Brian Stokes Mitchell has played Fred, Cervantes/Don Quixote, and Coalhouse, and is practically singing lounge songs now seems so....odd? I normally don't like Patti LuPone, but thought she was actually quite good last night. She played it straight without giving her normal inflections, or weird diction.
The audience response was pretty tepid last night, with the exception of only 2 songs. It really is kind of sad to think what the show could have been, but not everything can be perfect.
Also, to the person who asked, after the curtain came down, Danny Burstein spoke to the audience about giving BC/EFA donations at the exits.
-There's the muddle in the middle. There's the puddle where the poodle did the piddle."