I saw 110 IN THE SHADE this evening (Tuesday May 1) and thought that Ms. McDonald rises above a second rate musical, a largely (except for John Cullum) third rate supporting cast, a fourth rate director to create some moments of real magic.
I found there to be no chemistry whatsoever between Ms. McDonald and the actor playing Starbuck, who seemed to be under the impression that he was playing Jud Fry. He was dressed more like some sinister roadie out of a sleazy carnival than a charming con man: that long greasy hair didn't do him any favors in the looks department.
The kid playing Jimmy (Lizzie's brother) did the bare minimum, getting lots of laughs from easily amused members of the audience. A bigger problem is the actor playing Lizzie's other brother Noah, who just goes over the top, shouting and whining full blast. It is bad enough that he has to look Audra McDonald in the face and tell her that she's plain (HA! what actor alive could get away with that?!) but he does nothing to make me understand what the hell he might be talking about or why.
There's the big problem with the show, in a nutshell. Ms. McDonald is an astonishing beauty, full of light and joy and energy and passion, and the point is continually made, over and over and over again, that the character she's playing is NOT an astonishing beauty (at least partly because she's never had anyone tell her that she's beautiful). Ms. McDonald does her considerable best to convince that she doesn't believe she's pretty, but I kind of wanted to shout out that she should just get over it already, just take a look in the goddamn mirror, lady!
I've seen Ms. McDonald dowdy up before. She did it to memorable effect in RAISIN IN THE SUN, where she was tired and overworked and unhappy, unrecognizable until one remarkable moment when she just blossomed, it was like someone had turned on a lamp inside her. In 110 IN THE SHADE the lamp is always on, even when it shouldn't be.
"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW
"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick
My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/