MOULIN ROUGE! Broadway Casting Thread Feb 26
2026, 03:34:05 PM
"I want our industry to care more about our stage veterans"
Why would the industry care about stage veterans when audiences don't? Only a handful of "stage veterans" tour or play regional houses. They have no real fan base outside of NYC. Hiring a "stage veteran" for a show that's been running for a million years, aimed at tourists makes no sense.
People aren't compelled to see Danny Burstein becaus
|
Goodman’s Holiday to transfer? Feb 19
2026, 04:19:03 PM
" Maybe that is just part of their sales approach at this point."
It is... but this particular production is also it's not selling well. I'm not sure why... sounds like a smash on paper and the production itself is pretty swell.
|
Goodman’s Holiday to transfer? Feb 19
2026, 10:17:34 AM
I'm glad to hear somebody liked her performance. At a late preview I thought she was very obviously out of her depth. Looked GORGEOUS in her costumes tho. She was a Chicago actress... she did a brief stint here and moved to LA with her husband some time ago.
|
Goodman’s Holiday to transfer? Feb 19
2026, 09:54:14 AM
It's a lovely play and a lovely production (with a really terrible lead performance). Wesley Taylor and Molly Griggs are both exceptional in roles that might appear thankless in other hands. They need a magnetic star in the Katherine Hepburn part if they're planning to transfer. They don't grow on trees. Still, if they found one... I think it would be really something. It's also a role that a semi-capable actress without a lot of charisma could knock outta the park in her slee
|
Cynthia Erivo's Dracula - Terrifying Pics! Feb 17
2026, 04:20:03 PM
Bruce Willis was indeed lambasted while in Misery, online and in the press. It's sad to think it was maybe the beginning of his dementia. Al Pacino was also written about in the press about his earpiece in China Doll.
Both rightly, in my mind. While Erivo has the harder task, it's also the only thing you're going to see in Dracula. For me, an actor needing help navigating a role is understandable but keeping the audience's money for an unprepared show isn'
|
What happened to Julie Taymor? Jan 30
2026, 02:49:11 PM
I thought The Outsiders was a pretty middle of the road, sometimes silly, musical that was elevated by it's creative and iconic direction and design. Her production created real stakes that I don't think subsequent productions will be able to reach with just the material. I also thought she was able to craft a real sense of structure out of Pass Over which on the page reads pretty directionless to me. I realize that's partially the point of Pass Over, but I think Taymor's
|
What happened to Julie Taymor? Jan 30
2026, 12:04:35 PM
In an industry dominated by Nepo Babies... I'd really love if most of them had the talent that Danya Taymor does.
|
She has starred in New York’s ‘worst show’ for 40 years. Why? Jan 20
2026, 11:34:11 AM
The reading literacy crisis in this country (and elsewhere I guess) is really something.
|
Hamilton and Slavery - Unrevivable? Jan 15
2026, 09:35:11 AM
"I definitely agree with this to some extent but Hamilton goes so far as to imply Alexander was anti-slavery."
He was publicly and privately against slavery and actively fought against it when very few did. People and history are complicated. I agree that Hamilton sadly avoids that nuance, but that's not what the creators decided the show was about. Every show can't tell every story. Many other choices Miranda made actively violate the historical record, particularly
|
Vape or Don’t Vape? Dec 19
2025, 12:03:29 PM
They are probably talking about the musical currently running off-broadway, no?
|
“Roundabout Warns Studio 54 Could Close” Dec 18
2025, 11:25:09 AM
"Frankly I'd like to see nonprofits be forced to divest from their real estate holdings if they're not in active use by the nonprofit for a certain period of time. Why should Roundabout get to control and profit off the Sondheim when they haven't produced a show there in almost 15 years?"
Of all the weird bootlicking things posted on here... this is one of the weirder ones.
|
BUG Previews Dec 17
2025, 10:48:39 AM
I saw this a million years ago off-broadway and at Steppenwolf twice (both before the pandemic and after).
I liked this production a lot. It felt like it centered Agnes in a way that I did not feel the original did. Then it felt almost like a two-hander, here it feels like Agnes is what everything else revolves around. This was because Coon was so magnificent but also because I felt like Smallwood isn't nearly as alive and mysterious as Shannon was. Smallwood gave a terrific perfor
|
NYT: Jeremy O. Harris Is Arrested in Japan on Suspicion of Smuggling Drugs Dec 5
2025, 03:29:18 PM
"Who cares?" Gross. Dude sucks but we should care if even ****ty people are mistreated in prison. There's a lot of assumptions being made to get to "he's going to be discriminated against in prison" but "Who cares" is gross.
|
NYT: Jeremy O. Harris Is Arrested in Japan on Suspicion of Smuggling Drugs Dec 5
2025, 11:21:12 AM
That's maybe 10 pills. It's certainly possible he'll be convicted and spend time imprisoned but, I can't imagine his career is "cooked" if he goes free. This is not a serious amount of a drug that many people argue has a lot of therapeutic value. This is easily spinnable and, let's be serious, not that big of a deal.
Now. Is it extremely arrogant to think you can get away with something like this? Yea. He's the worst person. But the "crime&q
|
Paradise Road Cast Recording Dec 3
2025, 10:00:57 AM
It was already produced.
I realize everyone's first instinct on the internet is to criticize strangers but you really should do a google before posting.
|
NYT: It’s a Homophobic Slur. What’s It Doing in So Much Theater? Dec 1
2025, 12:58:54 PM
It's interesting to me because as a young person the idea of a "controversial title" was a little silly. Who gets upset about a word? BUT. With the popularity of Prince F----t I found that word all over the media I frequent and repeatedly in my inbox. Again, it's just a word and it doesn't bother me much... but having to confront that word over and over again alongside notifications from Redfin and NYTimes Cooking emails was really something.
The actual use
|
The Debate Over Colorblind Casting Isn’t Settled After All Nov 19
2025, 07:56:24 PM
"Here's the thing: The kind of middle/high schools that can put on a show like Hamilton will have money. Typically, those schools are more suburban and lean heavily white."
Aside from the revolve, Hamilton has almost no set on Broadway. I'm not sure what would prevent an extremely barebones staging. I don't think you even need period costumes.
|
NYT: Coming to the Metropolitan Opera: Sting and "The Last Ship" Nov 13
2025, 01:30:56 PM
dexter3 said: "I know I'm being terrible here, but....so now the Met is doing star casting? Yikes."
What a weirdly ignorant thing to say!
|
Jeremy O Harris’ Yell at the Majestic with Lakeith Stanfield? Nov 13
2025, 01:03:55 PM
"He’s become like a black Truman Capote."
You could have just said "like Truman Capote." Even then the comparison isn't apt. Capote had about 20 years of literary fame before sliding off the rails and was far more famous and significant than O'Harris could even dream of.
|
NYT: Tom Morello Brings Rage to an Unexpected Genre: the Musical “Revolution(s)” Oct 24
2025, 06:04:44 PM
That's interesting! At the preview, we saw, there was no mention of gay. There was... a nearly intimate moment between two characters but it stopped short of kissing or any mention of "gay."
I couldn't even tell if it was trying to be edgy? It just seemed... unfinished? There'd be a great line here or there... and certainly it COULD be a very timely story... it just felt unfinished and like even they weren't quite sure what story they were telling.&
|
You must log in to view off-topic posts.