Subway from a show
By any chance will anyone in your group have a car or are you traveling by bus the entire time? I grew up in the town next to Clark, you can take the North East Corridor NJ Transit train from Penn Station to Metropark station and have someone pick you up there if they have a car, or take a cab from there. The train ride will be $10 one way and the cab ride wont be more than 15-20 minutes max. Catching that 11:35 bus might not be doable after CABARET but the train is doable.