Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#1

Best Play Tony Award

So this week I took the time to see "Other Desert Cities" and "Chinglish."

I know "Other Desert Cities" is the front-runner, and rightfully so. It has great box-office appeal and stellar reviews. I did not care for it, however. The story just didn't grab me. I thought the direction was stilted and awkward at times. The actor was uniformly pretty good, but Rachel Griffiths was terrible. That could totally be up to her character, as I do not know her previous body of work. But she came off whiny and just uninteresting. I did not care for her character, so therefore I did not care for her story. I kept waiting for some "big moment" to happen that made me think "oh this is why everyone loves this show," but nothing came. The reveal at the end was so "and now what?" that I just did not care. The writing was so bland at that point that I had to fight myself to pay attention. I kept wanting to watch Judith Light's reactions to things rather than list to the actual information being given. The end monologue between the two parents has no climax and just sort of ends. And the ending is so Lifetime that it was hard to stay with it. That said, the acting was great, but I didn't feel like the material served its actors very well. In the end it just delved into a piece with everyone sitting around and crying, which is not interesting to watch, and not engaging.

On to Chinglish. I loved it. I know it's gotten a bad wrap on here, but I thought it was sharp, witty, and surprisingly beautiful. The acting in this show was superb. (I don't have my playbill with me, so forgive me).

The main actor was great. I thought he was just enough of the "fool" to make me come on board with him. I was interesting in his story and how it all sort of fell apart. The woman playing his "love interest" was also just hilarious and touching. The rest of the supporting players were great as well, which the "asian trio" being the standouts as the translators. Those scenes were the true gems of the production. If they could have showcased those on some sort of TV show or commercial, I think it would have gotten more people into the seats. The British actor wasn't my favorite. He would not stop rocking back and forth in the opening scene, and his character is kind of a shark, so it's hard to really like him, so I guess that means he was slightly successful.

The big ending scene between the American and the Chinese Vice-Minister was brilliant. It was so beautiful and hilarious. I was just astonished at the writing in that scene. Everything came full circle and was just beautiful to watch and figure out. My only major qualm with the show itself was with the Chinese Vice-Minister's two asides to the audience. It almost seemed out of place. It as if the play suddenly became about her character. I wouldn't have minded it if some of the other characters had asides, or if maybe she had done it in her first big scene, but it just caught me off guard. However, it was beautiful written and directed.

As people have said, the set is brilliant. It moves quickly and beautifully, and the direction with it is just stellar. I loved that they'd show him walking into the elevator or have little mini-scenes every time it rotated. All-in-all I really enjoyed it, and I'm sad it couldn't find a major following. It was really a great piece of theater.

---> I'm excited to see the other new plays opening this season. I missed "Clybourne Park" off-Broadway, so I'm excited for that. And "Peter and The Starcatchers" seems to have a good following on here, so I'm excited for that as well. Is "Stick Fly" worth checking out? What are your thoughts on the two aforementioned shows? I'm always curious to know why someone liked/disliked a certain show.
#2

Best Play Tony Award

I've never seen her live, but Rachel Griffiths is a very fine film and TV actor.

I've only read the play, but I found the "big reveal" of ODC underwhelming, too.
#3

Best Play Tony Award

It's funny. I hated Other Desert Cities off-Broadway (I saw it early in previews before all of the rave reviews from audiences and critics alike happened). I think they tightened it a lot after I saw it though. Before seeing it on Broadway, I would have said Chinglish was better. But after seeing Other Desert Cities on Broadway a few weeks ago, I was pleased with the quality of the production. And honestly, Rachel Griffiths was one of my favorite parts of the new cast. I actually liked her more than Judith Light (I still think Linda Lavin was better, and I LOVE Judith normally).
#4

Best Play Tony Award

I think it's going to be Clybourne Park's Tony to lose. Unless the cast and direction are horrific misfires, the play itself is very strong. With the Olivier, Pulitzer and Evening Standard awards under its belt, and its meta content inspired by one of the great American plays, it's going to be the toughest play to beat this season.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
#5

Best Play Tony Award

Though it's been done previously to great acclaim in New York, does Wit stand a chance, as this is its Broadway premiere?
For arts and culture commentary, along with other assorted opinions, visit WEEPING ON WHEELS at http://weepingonwheels.tumblr.com/
#6

Best Play Tony Award

Wit will almost certainly be considered a revival under the classics rule.
"You travel alone because other people are only there to remind you how much that hook hurts that we all bit down on. Wait for that one day we can bite free and get back out there in space where we belong, sail back over water, over skies, into space, the hook finally out of our mouths and we wander back out there in space spawning to other planets never to return hurrah to earth and we'll look back and can't even see these lives here anymore. Only the taste of blood to remind us we ever existed. The earth is small. We're gone. We're dead. We're safe." -John Guare, Landscape of the Body
#7

Best Play Tony Award

Wit will probably be in the Revival category. It's been around for 15 years and has been staged regionally all over the country for over 10 years.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
#8

Best Play Tony Award

I would love to see what Lavin did with the role. It seemed like a very ballsy, loud character, but then she quickly delved into Lifetime-y advice, which I thought was just a little out-of-character for all that proceeded it.
#9

Best Play Tony Award

Going back to ODC, I found the reveal to be totally shocking and completely devastating. Once it comes you completely understand these characters (the parents, specifically) and everything you felt about them for the past two hours is totally thrown away and I LOVE THAT. I've seen the play four times and each time my jaw is on the floor for the last fifteen minutes.
#10

Best Play Tony Award

Really? See, I'm not one to try and "solve" a show before it happens, so I wasn't trying to guess what was coming, but when it was revealed I just felt like "okay, yeah...so now what?" I mean, I knew something was coming, and I guess I was just expecting more twists and turns rather than just one big reveal at the end. And the reveal was just sort of along the lines of what I expected. There people all around me crying and whatnot, and I just felt so confused as to how they were all so emotionally invested. I didn't get it.
#11

Best Play Tony Award

****SPOILER*****









To me it's so emotional because once it's revealed, you finally understand these people. They're not mean or uncaring people. They did what any parent in that situation would do - Protect their child even if it means never seeing him again and letting their daughter suffer just so he could live. It all of a sudden turns the entire story on it's head and smacks you in the face with reality and that these are real people who have been suffering for most of their lives holding this secret in. And I found it devastating.
#12

Best Play Tony Award

With the Olivier, Pulitzer and Evening Standard awards under its belt, and its meta content inspired by one of the great American plays, it's going to be the toughest play to beat this season.

For what it's worth, the Clybourne Park that won the Olivier and Evening Standard awards was a VERY different production than the off-Broadway one. Having seen the off-Broadway production of the show, which is the one coming to Broadway, I think Other Desert Cities has a better shot since the production itself is stronger. As for the Pulitzer, Clybourne Park won a few years ago, but Other Desert Cities is a STRONG contender this year.
#13

Best Play Tony Award

Okay true, I can get on board with that point of view. But to me the way the information was delivered just wasn't the best writing. It just seemed to drag on and on and on and on to the point where I found it hard to pay attention. I was more interested in watching the other actors reactions than the actual information that was being delivered. I just wish the scene had built to a bigger climax. And the point where Griffith's character suddenly breaks out and starts crying was a little too stagey for my tastes.
#14

Best Play Tony Award

*****SPOILER*****







How was that stagey? She bursts out crying when her parents tell her that the brother that she thought was dead was alive and that he didnt want to hurt her. It was something I think most people would have done.
#15

Best Play Tony Award

The way it was delivered - to me - was a little "oh come on." I understand the emotional impact, but I would have preferred a more silent reaction instead of a stagey "oh woah is me" type of crying. It's all preference.
#16

Best Play Tony Award

***More spoilers****

I think the entire play up until that point does a great job of building up just how crucial the loss of her brother was to Brooke's life. It's the most devastating element of it. Even after all those years, the grief of it is so overwhelming to her that she has a breakdown and can't write until she purges this from her into her book. And when all the work she has done to try to accept this tragic part of her life is finally collected and packaged up in this book that she is so proud of, it all topples down on top of her once again in finding out the real truth. I think that is sufficient reason to break down into tears.

And I also completely agree with Jordan that the reveal is shocking and brilliantly done. In fact, I felt like it was perfectly paced and not drawn out at all. It comes fast and furious, steamrolling to the end of the play. The stage picture of the papers flying across the stage amidst this group of actors playing this stunning scene is amongst the most eye-popping and intense things I've ever seen on a stage. Is it obvious enough that I loved this play?
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim
#17

Best Play Tony Award

To each their own! "Fast and furious" is not something I would ever use to describe the end of this play. I was so bored. But to each their own. Like I said I loved Chinglish and found it really beautiful, but my friends who saw it hated it and thought it was so slight. So that's the joy of theater!

I just don't enjoy theater that isn't theatrical. ODC could easily, and probably will be, a movie. It would be easy to transfer it to the screen. There is nothing inherently theatrical about it. And I'm not a fan of a play where the characters just sit around and bitch and moan about things. I'd rather see a plot unfolding rather than "secrets" being revealed. So to each their own.

And why is the Off-Broadway production of Clybourne coming rather than the National Production that got raves? I remember the Playwright Horizon's version not getting that good of reviews. And I was surprised Clybourne was even a contender for the Pulitzer.
#18

Best Play Tony Award

They've actually already announced a film version is in the works.
#19

Best Play Tony Award

Baitz' work almost always reminds me of television. Well-written TV--I don't mean it's schlock--but TV, nonetheless. I'd just as soon watch the same material on pay cable.
#20

Best Play Tony Award

Thanks all for the clarification about Wit!

This ODC debate is quite interesting. I too was slightly underwhelmed by the revaluation itself, though I thought Channing and Keach's deliveries to be absolutely stunning. I agree with RippedMan about Rachel Griffiths stagey burst of tears, but I also agree with Jordan that the implications of the reveal make such an impact because of the sudden shift in sympathy toward these two polarizing parents.
For arts and culture commentary, along with other assorted opinions, visit WEEPING ON WHEELS at http://weepingonwheels.tumblr.com/
#21

Best Play Tony Award

It's interesting that people think her burst of tears is over the top. Imagine finding out everything you thought you knew your entire life was a lie. That burst of emotion most certainly could come out of somebody. There wasn't one false moment in it to me.
#22

Best Play Tony Award

I've just never heard a noise like that come out of another human being. Granted I have never experienced that kind of betrayal, and I imagine people in tremendous grief would be capable of such audible sorrow. To me, however, it seemed uncharacteristic of the Brooke I had just gotten to know for two hours.
For arts and culture commentary, along with other assorted opinions, visit WEEPING ON WHEELS at http://weepingonwheels.tumblr.com/
#23

Best Play Tony Award

"Bz' work almost always reminds me of Well-written TV--I don't mean it's schlock--but TV, nonetheless. I'd just as soon watch the same material on pay cable."
It's too bad ABC screwed him so badly with Brothers and Sisters which was actually often great under him--until ABC started telling him to get less political, to focus less on the older cast (ironic as after he left the *three* sets of headwriters who replaced him one after another at least realized the main appeal was the older cast), forced a whole character on him--the blonde bimbo the brothers worked and slept with (who quickly was written out when Baitz left) etc. His production blog about why he left was great--and of course ABC managed to have it removed and we were stuck with years of that maudlin crap of a show.

#24

Best Play Tony Award

Eh. I think my problem with her crying came from the fact that I just couldn't get on board with her character. It was all very whiny - which is totally in line with what people were saying about her character. I just couldn't support her. I honestly was on the parent's/brother's side for most of the show, so maybe that's why? And it just seems like when that amount of information is thrown onto you, I would think, you would respond in a much more subtler way because you're still processing all the information. It's the first time you've heard it, you're still making sense of it all. Plus, her character just doesn't seem that dramatic. She's very much the liberal hippie of the group. I don't know any of my hippie/pothead friends that would ever have that reaction to something.
#25

Best Play Tony Award

caught Clybourne Park in LA the other night and was totally impressed. really well written with carefully fleshed out characters, steller direction, exceptional ensemble acting and a bit of a coup du theater - without giving away anything.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71