#1
Posted: 1/25/12 at 2:41am
So this week I took the time to see "Other Desert Cities" and "Chinglish."
I know "Other Desert Cities" is the front-runner, and rightfully so. It has great box-office appeal and stellar reviews. I did not care for it, however. The story just didn't grab me. I thought the direction was stilted and awkward at times. The actor was uniformly pretty good, but Rachel Griffiths was terrible. That could totally be up to her character, as I do not know her previous body of work. But she came off whiny and just uninteresting. I did not care for her character, so therefore I did not care for her story. I kept waiting for some "big moment" to happen that made me think "oh this is why everyone loves this show," but nothing came. The reveal at the end was so "and now what?" that I just did not care. The writing was so bland at that point that I had to fight myself to pay attention. I kept wanting to watch Judith Light's reactions to things rather than list to the actual information being given. The end monologue between the two parents has no climax and just sort of ends. And the ending is so Lifetime that it was hard to stay with it. That said, the acting was great, but I didn't feel like the material served its actors very well. In the end it just delved into a piece with everyone sitting around and crying, which is not interesting to watch, and not engaging.
On to Chinglish. I loved it. I know it's gotten a bad wrap on here, but I thought it was sharp, witty, and surprisingly beautiful. The acting in this show was superb. (I don't have my playbill with me, so forgive me).
The main actor was great. I thought he was just enough of the "fool" to make me come on board with him. I was interesting in his story and how it all sort of fell apart. The woman playing his "love interest" was also just hilarious and touching. The rest of the supporting players were great as well, which the "asian trio" being the standouts as the translators. Those scenes were the true gems of the production. If they could have showcased those on some sort of TV show or commercial, I think it would have gotten more people into the seats. The British actor wasn't my favorite. He would not stop rocking back and forth in the opening scene, and his character is kind of a shark, so it's hard to really like him, so I guess that means he was slightly successful.
The big ending scene between the American and the Chinese Vice-Minister was brilliant. It was so beautiful and hilarious. I was just astonished at the writing in that scene. Everything came full circle and was just beautiful to watch and figure out. My only major qualm with the show itself was with the Chinese Vice-Minister's two asides to the audience. It almost seemed out of place. It as if the play suddenly became about her character. I wouldn't have minded it if some of the other characters had asides, or if maybe she had done it in her first big scene, but it just caught me off guard. However, it was beautiful written and directed.
As people have said, the set is brilliant. It moves quickly and beautifully, and the direction with it is just stellar. I loved that they'd show him walking into the elevator or have little mini-scenes every time it rotated. All-in-all I really enjoyed it, and I'm sad it couldn't find a major following. It was really a great piece of theater.
---> I'm excited to see the other new plays opening this season. I missed "Clybourne Park" off-Broadway, so I'm excited for that. And "Peter and The Starcatchers" seems to have a good following on here, so I'm excited for that as well. Is "Stick Fly" worth checking out? What are your thoughts on the two aforementioned shows? I'm always curious to know why someone liked/disliked a certain show.
I know "Other Desert Cities" is the front-runner, and rightfully so. It has great box-office appeal and stellar reviews. I did not care for it, however. The story just didn't grab me. I thought the direction was stilted and awkward at times. The actor was uniformly pretty good, but Rachel Griffiths was terrible. That could totally be up to her character, as I do not know her previous body of work. But she came off whiny and just uninteresting. I did not care for her character, so therefore I did not care for her story. I kept waiting for some "big moment" to happen that made me think "oh this is why everyone loves this show," but nothing came. The reveal at the end was so "and now what?" that I just did not care. The writing was so bland at that point that I had to fight myself to pay attention. I kept wanting to watch Judith Light's reactions to things rather than list to the actual information being given. The end monologue between the two parents has no climax and just sort of ends. And the ending is so Lifetime that it was hard to stay with it. That said, the acting was great, but I didn't feel like the material served its actors very well. In the end it just delved into a piece with everyone sitting around and crying, which is not interesting to watch, and not engaging.
On to Chinglish. I loved it. I know it's gotten a bad wrap on here, but I thought it was sharp, witty, and surprisingly beautiful. The acting in this show was superb. (I don't have my playbill with me, so forgive me).
The main actor was great. I thought he was just enough of the "fool" to make me come on board with him. I was interesting in his story and how it all sort of fell apart. The woman playing his "love interest" was also just hilarious and touching. The rest of the supporting players were great as well, which the "asian trio" being the standouts as the translators. Those scenes were the true gems of the production. If they could have showcased those on some sort of TV show or commercial, I think it would have gotten more people into the seats. The British actor wasn't my favorite. He would not stop rocking back and forth in the opening scene, and his character is kind of a shark, so it's hard to really like him, so I guess that means he was slightly successful.
The big ending scene between the American and the Chinese Vice-Minister was brilliant. It was so beautiful and hilarious. I was just astonished at the writing in that scene. Everything came full circle and was just beautiful to watch and figure out. My only major qualm with the show itself was with the Chinese Vice-Minister's two asides to the audience. It almost seemed out of place. It as if the play suddenly became about her character. I wouldn't have minded it if some of the other characters had asides, or if maybe she had done it in her first big scene, but it just caught me off guard. However, it was beautiful written and directed.
As people have said, the set is brilliant. It moves quickly and beautifully, and the direction with it is just stellar. I loved that they'd show him walking into the elevator or have little mini-scenes every time it rotated. All-in-all I really enjoyed it, and I'm sad it couldn't find a major following. It was really a great piece of theater.
---> I'm excited to see the other new plays opening this season. I missed "Clybourne Park" off-Broadway, so I'm excited for that. And "Peter and The Starcatchers" seems to have a good following on here, so I'm excited for that as well. Is "Stick Fly" worth checking out? What are your thoughts on the two aforementioned shows? I'm always curious to know why someone liked/disliked a certain show.