Swing Joined: 8/26/14
Hello,
I was chatting with a friend recently and we were discussing window cards that have been hard to find. I told him about Triton gallery and he said that the prices were too high for his taste (Personally I find them quite reasonable and the quality is amazing). Anyway, he said that he wanted to try making his own by taking an image of the poster online and making one in one of those custom poster websites because he found it to be way cheaper. I told him that this was illegal because he was taking property that wasn't his (the image of the original poster) and having it printed. Was I wrong in telling him that it was illegal? I was under the impression that it was because it was stealing but I wasn't really sure. Any insight into this matter would be greatly appreciated.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/18/11
It is in fact illegal. The artist who created the art or the producer who paid to have it created owns the copyright to the work and it can't be used without permission. It is, however, highly unenforceable, unless you're selling them.
Swing Joined: 8/26/14
That's exactly what I told him but he said the same thing-that nobody is going to see it but him and he doesn't plan on doing anything with it besides having it in a personal collection. But the fact of the matter is that it is still illegal no matter what his plans for it are.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/18/11
There's no harm done if it's for his personal collection. It's also illegal to photocopy a page out of a book at the library, but if you're taking it home as part of your research for a term paper, no one is going to make a fuss over it. It's when you profit from it that things get dicey.
Swing Joined: 8/26/14
What do you think the odds of him getting caught doing it are? Realistically?
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/18/11
No one seems to care when those Times Square street vendors sell framed colored prints of Broadway show art. Many of them are just reproductions of the playbill cover, but still.
Updated On: 5/6/15 at 11:41 PM
I would imagine the quality would be very blurry. Has he tried eBay? They have original window cards there for way cheaper than Triton Gallery.
Swing Joined: 8/26/14
He did try ebay, but he could not find the one he was looking for. The only ones they had were signed and cost 100+ dollars.
It's definitely illegal, but he's right thinking that he won't get caught... but it won't be very good quality either.
There are some great reproductions on amazon of old Broadway posters. It would be cool if in the future those images could just be available online to order whenever someone wanted to print them. You could pay a small fee as a "lease" and print yourself a copy.
Swing Joined: 8/26/14
It would definitely be cool. For some reason the poster he was looking for was prematurely discontinued so it has been absolutely impossible to find. Realistically how bad do you think the overall quality would be?
Swing Joined: 8/26/14
@Fantod
Like me, he's looking for a window card from once. I told him that they were discontinued and that's when he got the idea just to make his own...and that's how we got here.
Edit: Apparently he's looking for a lot of others as well but he's only told me of the one. I guess he wanted to know if it would work for one before trying others?
Updated On: 5/7/15 at 12:25 AM
Well Once is on Triton for a discounted price ($45 instead of $75), and I'd say that that's only a few more dollars than the price to print your own 14 by 22 window card, plus the dramatic increase in quality.
Swing Joined: 8/26/14
I told him about the one on Triton and for him it would be $45 for the poster and then $16 for the shipping. He thinks that $61 in total is too expensive. Maybe I should just tell him to order the movie version of the poster instead? If he's that insistent on having one?
Videos