I have one word for you, and that word is "postseason." Jeter's in, easily, whether you choose to believe it's based on merit or just on the fact that it's baseball writers who do the voting. :)
Anyway, yeah, we had a high-offense era which will be difficult to compare with other eras. But that's happened throughout baseball history with changes like the switch to the live ball around 1920 and the lowering of the mound in 1969. Fact is, we also have a remarkable generation of shortstops right now, and it's not just an offensive era thing- they're producing, as hitters relative to their contemporaries in other positions, at historical levels.
As it stands, I think A-Rod and Jeter are getting in, though maybe not as shortstops, with Nomar joining them if he ever stops with the disastrous injuries. Tejada still has some catching up to do.
Funny how an era of unbridled offense produced 4 of the best pitchers of all time, too. We're kind of short on great third basemen, though.
ETA- Sorry, liotte; I'm going to the Fringe on Sunday.
Updated On: 8/9/05 at 12:55 AM