Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
#326

re: Heroes

The big issue was that Nathan didn't need to do it.
It wasn't just that she couldn't shoot him- she knew he wouldn't die, and if she didn't then the entire city would blow up, killing her dad too. Also, with Sprague earlier she didn't even have to kill him, just knock him out, why the heck couldn't she do that?

I like that they decided to make Nathan make the sacrifice, but it just really made no sense that he did.

It seems that being torn on it is common:
Erin at TWOP loved the episode:
http://www.televisionwithoutpity.com/articles/content/a13124
while the EW recapper was very disappointed:
http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20039679,00.html

I stand corrected, you are as vapid as they say.

Updated On: 5/22/07 at 09:00 AM

#327

re: Heroes

NBC annouced a week and a halk ago that there is going to be a spin-off called Heroes: Origins.

My question is, why couldn't Peter fly himself away? He had already aborbed Nathan's power to fly.

Updated On: 5/22/07 at 10:46 AM

#328

re: Heroes

Had we ever seen Peter fly on his own?

I thought he had not learned how to control that power yet.

Updated On: 5/22/07 at 11:03 AM

#329

re: Heroes

I would have loved to have seen Nikki kick a little more ass.
#330

re: Heroes

I would have loved to have seen Nikki kick a little more ass.

Are we to assume that Sylar is still alive? Did he drag himself into the manhole. Can her regenerate now? I thought he had to kill someone in order to absorb their power.
#331

re: Heroes

I wondered about the manhole flash, too.

Peter can fly on his own, but I assume that when he's in distress as he was at that moment, he doesn't have control over his powers. But I agree that Claire -- or Nathan, for that matter -- could as easily have shot him with the same results and without the sacrifice. Though I guess they'd only feel safe if Peter stayed "dead" or the explosion happened and they averted it, so Nathan sacrificed himself to allow Peter to live out his destiny without hurting anyone. (I disagree with Erin that Peter is dead).

Updated On: 5/22/07 at 11:16 AM

#332

re: Heroes

Re: Sylar, my guess is that he was playing "chicken" with Hiro, since he was unable to get him the first time. I also figure he's so powerful, even though he can't regenerate like Claire and Peter, a mere sword through the torso would not kill him.

Re: Nathan, redemption requires sacrifice in these kinds of stories.
Celebrate Life

Experience is what you get when you didn't get what you wanted. - Randy Pausch

#333

re: Heroes

"NBC annouced a week and a halk ago that there is going to be a spin-off called Heroes: Origins."

"The "Origins" series will consist of six stand-alone episodes, with each one introducing a new character and telling his or her back story. They'll take place within the "Heroes" universe but won't be tied into the main arc of the series, although one or two regular characters may pop up."
"Smart! And into all those exotic mystiques -- The Kama Sutra and Chinese techniques. I hear she knows more than seventy-five. Call me tomorrow if you're still alive!"
#334

re: Heroes

I think that Claire and Peter both thought that a bullet to the head would have actually killed him. Both of them have had brain injuries that kept them from healing themselves and it would be a much more difficult task to get the bullet out than it was to pull out the large piece of glass. I'm sure she was hoping that some alternative would present itself so she wouldn't have to kill him. Although I do agree that since all she had to do earlier in the season was knock Ted out there was some annoying inconsistancy.

I agree that some elements of the finale were a little lame, especially Simone's father's speech about love. But, I really liked Nathan sacrificing himself to save everyone else. And I have no doubt that Peter survived.
#335

re: Heroes

Here's my take: Notice that most, if not all of the 'good guys' have just recently come to know and/or use their powers. The 'bad guys' (Nathan straddled the line throughout) are coming from a place of knowing their gifts and using them mostly for 'evil' So it makes sense that these 'newbies' and their power come from a very emotional place. Why didn't Peter just fly away by himself? He was FREAKED OUT to start with and was in possession of a very unstable power, so it makes sense to me that he was near frozen in fear. Claire couldnt' bring herself to shoot someone she loved, another emotional moment.

To have them just do an all out assault on Sylar would have been way to X-Men for my taste. I like the human aspect of these 'mutants.' A good ending to a great season, leaving me panting for more.
#336

re: Heroes

This show desperately needs help in continuity. It seems that they simply write whatever they want to make a given story work out with NO interest in how it affects the overall story.

I agree that Peter may have had trouble controling any of his powers, but it does not make the "forced sacrifice" any less lame. Out of 20 possible solutions they picked the one that forced "redemption" on Nathan, but is it really a sacrifice at all- he honestly did not need to do it.
Again, Ted was 100 times closer to blowing up earlier in the season, doesn't even have regenerating power and Claire stopped him without killing him.

Sylar was obviously not dead, and it seems odd that they thought he was, it was again ridiculous.


I stand corrected, you are as vapid as they say.
#337

re: Heroes

Remember that when Clare stopped Ted she has some sort of shot that she had to give him, and they made it really clear that there was nothing that anyone could do that could stop the explosion, it was going to happen. I think that if Clare would have shot him that it was have triggered the explosion, and that Peter tried anything, he would explode, and that Nathan making that scarrifice was the only solution.
#338

re: Heroes

That seems pretty obviously what they want you to think, it just does not follow from the events of the show at all.
They only made it clear that this explosion was going to happen by constantly saying it was going to happen. It was incredibly shoddily executed.
I stand corrected, you are as vapid as they say.
#339

re: Heroes

ted had time (years?) to get used to and control his power. peter did not. and from the way the events unfolded it suggested the peter was much stronger/powerful than ted ever was. remember ted never exploded or came close to it, so there is no "continuity problem."

and it was suggested that the convergence of all the heroes and their powers coming together in peter may have also led to his instability/nuclear-ness.
XING
PED
#340

re: Heroes

I agree, RobbO. The other powers he used at will, but that one just seemed to happen and he just seemed to have no control over it.
Celebrate Life

Experience is what you get when you didn't get what you wanted. - Randy Pausch

#341

re: Heroes

"Ted had time (years?) to get used to and control his power. peter did not. and from the way the events unfolded it suggested the peter was much stronger/powerful than ted ever was. remember ted never exploded or came close to it, so there is no "continuity problem." "
That is not what they presented in the show at all- Ted had little to no control over his power (blowing up the FBI van, killing his wife, and blowing up the Bennett's house were all decidedly "accidental")

It is true that Peter did not have good control over the nuclear power, and there may be some truth to the "all the heroes were there" theory. But it all simply boils down to- it was sloppily executed, and left me very disappointed.

Again, I actually like what happened, it is just very frustrating to see how these last three episodes played out.
Starting from the point where I actually decided to give the creators credit for a great show, it got very slack.

It is because I really enjoyed the show all year and that I think they could have done a much better job that I am so critical of this finale. I wanted great, would have settled for well developed, and got disjointed.

There were some tremendous moments, when Nathan decided to help Peter being one of them, and the Claire and Horned Rim Glasses moments remained top notch.

I also thought the "epilogue" was quite interesting. It is fun to think that they could develop an entire history, a Heroesverse, if they were willing to put some time and thought into it.




I stand corrected, you are as vapid as they say.
#342

re: Heroes

Peter could have flown off on his own, I guess.

But it didn't seem like he could do much of anything - he was using all his energy to control "the bomb."
#343

heroes

i
i wish you could swim
like the dolphins
like dolphins can swim
r.i.p. marco, my guardian angel.

...global warming can manifest itself as heat, cool, precipitation, storms, drought, wind, or any other phenomenon, much like a shapeshifter. -- jim geraghty

pray to st. jude

i'm a sonic reducer

he was the gimmicky sort

fenchurch=mejusthavingfun=magwildwood=mmousefan=bkcollector=bradmajors=somethingtotalkabout: the fenchurch mpd collective
#344

heroes

Ted's powers were triggered by emotion (That's how the wife bit it), so it makes sense that emotions are a bit harder to control.
#345

Heroes

Well, obviously Peter was in no control of his powers, that's the reason he was about to explode in the first place. If he couldn't control the radiation power, why would he be able to control the flying one?
Also, the only way Claire could stop Peter was by shooting him in a specific part of his brain, the same part that Claire pierced when she was about to get raped, and the part that Sylar put the glass through when he "killed" Peter. They could have always removed the bullet afterwards so I don't know.
In reality, the episode was very anti-climatic towards the end. Everyone kept saying that the two episodes before were boring because they were setting everything up for a big finale...I'm still waiting.
I'd be quite upset if season 2 deals with a bunch of different characters. I'd be even more upset if Sylar is alive indeed, we had enough of him in this season, he proved to be boring at the end, move on. I suppose season 2 could deal with this man that Molly saw--anyone else thinks that Molly will be adopted by DL and Nikki? I was hoping DL would die so Nikki and Peter could end up together, but oh well.
Is Greg Grunberg out of this show as well? He never finishes a show, does he?
"Some people can thrive and bloom living life in a living room, that's perfect for some people of one hundred and five. But I at least gotta try, when I think of all the sights that I gotta see, all the places I gotta play, all the things that I gotta be at"
#346

Heroes

Eh, I was not very impressed with the finale, it was alright though, I guess. But for something that the entire season was building up to, it seemed like it was kind of thrown together without much care. There were so many weird moments and what seemed like wasted time when they really should have been cramming every minute of this episode to tie up everything that had happened the whole season.

The absolute most ridiculous part of the episode had to be when Peter had his "vision" of the past when he was a nurse.

Peter: What is this, a dream?
Simone's dad: Does it really matter? That's not important.

Like honestly, the writers couldn't figure out what the hell was going on? That was infuriating/so absurd.
#347

Heroes

Oh, I agree, that was such a cop-out. They could've explained it as Peter time-traveling or something else. The whole "love" speech was a bit too corny. That was one of the weakest moments of the show.
"Some people can thrive and bloom living life in a living room, that's perfect for some people of one hundred and five. But I at least gotta try, when I think of all the sights that I gotta see, all the places I gotta play, all the things that I gotta be at"
#348

Heroes

I figured it had to be time traveling...but yeah that was kinda a cop out.
#349

Heroes

I think that part of what I was a little disappointed with was that they never dealt with the set-up for the five years in the future episode. They didn't have to given that everything could well have happened after the bomb, but it would have been cool to see how we would have ended up with that future if the bomb went off (e.g. Nikki and Peter meeting, for example).

The finale was good, it just didn't pack any punches or twists that one would expect in the season finale of this type of show.
#350

Heroes

from zap2it.com:

We can now answer, more or less definitively, one of the burning questions about the finale of Heroes in May. To wit: Why the heck couldn't Peter fly away by himself?

"Here's how it was explained to me," says Adrian Pasdar, who plays' Peter's (Milo Ventimiglia) brother Nathan and who ferried him to the sky to explode. "He was unstable, unable to control his powers. And if he did fly off he wouldn't have been able to control" any of the other powers he'd absorbed, most pertinently the explodability Peter got from Ted Sprague.

One gets the sense the actors have been asked this question a couple times. Jack "HRG" Coleman, standing next to Pasdar at a press event on the Heroes soundstage Thursday, notes that the answer was in the show: "There was a line where he actually said, 'I can't do anything.'"

(The full line, which Peter says to Nathan shortly after he flies into Kirby Plaza, is "I took his power. I can't control it. I can't do anything.")
why peter could not fly.
XING
PED

Updated On: 6/25/07 at 02:48 PM

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $60
Hot Show
Tickets From $71