FULL DISCLOSURE: I've only heard the tracks available on Spotify because I don't have a "Madonna albums" line item on my unemployment benefits budget. So, I can forget about full albums let alone $400 concert tickets.
But, anyway, beyond the wonderful gospel-house explosion of "Living for Love", a surprisingly tender and effectively vulnerable "Joan of Arc", and a pretty... tolerable "Ghosttown", I'm kind of shocked at how bad everything else is. And I don't just mean the appalling lyrics. I honestly think part of the problem is the producers she's chosen to work with. So many of them - despite their credits - are primarily and essentially edc producers - more concerned with a beat or a sound effect than with songwriting and songcraft or production of the human voice. I don't think this has served her well here at all. In that Pitchfork interview she was asked who in today's pop music scene is stimulating her and she basically said "no one", but then said that although he's not really pop, she loves what James Blake is doing. Well, yeah, James Blake is ****ing amazing. If only she'd been able to convince someone like James Blake (a great producer, yes, but a just as talented
musician) to work with her, things might have been better. I'm still looking forward to hearing the remaining tracks, but, man, is most of what I've heard thus far monumentally disappointing. Makes MDNA seem so much better and I can't believe I'm saying that.
BTW, although I haven't heard "Body Shop" yet, and so can't comment on the accuracy of it, this quote from the EW 'review' made me genuinely L-O-L:
“Body Shop” has the most natural vocals on the album; Madonna sounds like an actual human woman instead of Siri singing Fifty Shades of Grey on low batteries. The funny, creative, outrageous Madonna we’ve known is still in here somewhere. It just takes a lot of patience to find her.
Updated On: 3/5/15 at 07:56 PM