Broadway Legend Joined: 6/20/05
Sure it does.
You had to pick three and you failed because JRB is ineligible as he's had his day.
JRB is eliminated automatically.. choose from Robbo's other two please
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/20/05
That's not fair, Craig.
You are not giving three choices then, and people can just put two names in that have been picked that way.
Updated On: 6/22/06 at 10:25 AM
Well then - we can worry about that in the future.. I don't believe Robbo did it intentionally.. my "ruling" is that we choose from the two that are eligible. Thanks :)
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/20/05
You need to uphold your rules, not revise them just for RobbO.
i eliminate poppy.
quit crying nom. isn't it time for you to medidate?
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/20/05
Rules are objective.
"Intentions" are subjective.
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/20/05
I request that Rob moderate this decision as well.
Appeal to Rob.
Intervention.
Nom. I don't know if you're being "cute" or not. But if you want to get technical - there's no rule about who people nominate (which I can and will change) there's a rule who can BE selected as the COTD.
There's nothing to moderate, and there's nothing to appeal.
erikj972 it is.
Betty loves Phanty.
Congratulations, Erik! One of the smartest, most charming and sexiest posters ever!
There's precedent for this. A few pages backs, SOMMS' nominations included BdwayGirl, and she won -- until it was pointed out that she had already been chosen previously. So, it went to the previous one eliminated, Shira.
I want to be one of those invisible Jeopardy judges to whom Alex Trebek always refers questionable answers, er, questions.
congrats, erik. nice to see an old timer (on the board, not in age) be recognized.
Usurper, uschmurper.
Congrats Erik!
Nice. Erik has already made me giggle today.
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/20/05
But, Calvin, I have come in and timely pointed out the error and the failure so the situation is different here.
I like that my becoming COTD happened with some controversy.
now there's a surprise.
And that you won out over a sock-puppet!
If only Kerry could have done that.
now there's the erik we know and love! *grumble, grumble*
I've asked for an official ruling.
She recounted and says the new celeb du jour is:
George W. Bush!
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/20/05
Fair is foul and foul is fair...
i wonder if jeb has his whole hand in or just his thumb?
i don't think jeb is erik's type. although he did say that he winds up sleeping with the people he loathes....
Videos