I think BIRTH has the most promising first hour of any of her films. I was so there, and its start-up is riveting, the premise fresh and in every way compelling. The production design, upper west side location, damp milieu and blue/gray cinematography ... even Ann Heche as an eye-popping weirdo, a stretch I know. And then ...then the movie falls apart with such a shattering thud, the premise exposed, the mystery thisdeep, and the explanation bald and ham-fisted in the telling. You feel so cheated ... lead down a creepy path only to have the revelations pitifully unsatisfying.
How could such talent and creative energy be lavished on what's ultimately a dreadful script -- on that poses metaphysical questions and provides Perry Mason answers. Why did no one know how bad it was? You could not, finally, argue that it was an ambitious story -- just a cheat.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling