I really just do not understand the "too old" thing. People make the argument without acknowledging that there have been actors throughout the entire run who were in their mid-thirties. It isn't a problem because Adam and Anthony are 35/6. It's a problem because that information is inevitably very public.
Amazing doesn't even BEGIN to cover them. They are... I don't even know. Powerful and intense and beautiful and... perfect.
Chloe, exactly. I was kind of like, "Phantom? What? Really?" I'd certainly see it, but I can't really picture it -- it's the last thing I'd expect. I can see him making a great Billy Flynn -- not only does the role require talent, but further, it's reliant on sex appeal and charm.
A work of art is an invitation to love.